Can Yankees’ Josh Donaldson turn things around in 2023?

josh donaldson, yankees

When the New York Yankees acquired Josh Donaldson to man the hot corner, it was a completely mixed bag of feelings from the fanbase.

The Yankees sent fan favorite Gio Urshela and Gary Sanchez to the Twins in exchange for JD and IKF, as well as Ben Rortvedt. At the time of the trade, I was on the side that was saying, “hey, this could actually be a sneaky good move.” Needless to say, it was anything but that, as Josh Donaldson quickly skyrocketed up the hitlist for Yanks fans worldwide.

Donaldson’s skill is certainly not in question, and when one takes a look back at his career stats, there’s no doubting just how talented he was.

Sadly, the keyword there is “was.” Donaldson was absolutely putrid offensively, and in the postseason, he was one of the many guys who seemingly fell off the face of the earth. Most notably, he was seen laughing as he went back to the dugout following a strike three, looking on a hanger right down the middle of the plate in the ALCS. That moment seemed to be the final nail in the coffin for how his first season as a Yankee went, and many believe that that is the version of JD that is here to stay.

Apr 30, 2024; New York City, New York, USA; New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso (20) against the Chicago Cubs during the first inning at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Gregory Fisher-USA TODAY Sports, yankees
Credit: Gregory Fisher-USA TODAY Sports

The Yankees have 4 big-time bats they could acquire at the deadline to reinforce first base

As the end of July approaches in a few weeks, Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman is poised to be aggressive […]
May 25, 2024; San Diego, California, USA; New York Yankees center fielder Aaron Judge (99)celebrates with shortstop Anthony Volpe (11) after a two run home run in the first inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Chadd Cady-USA TODAY Sports
Credit: Chadd Cady-USA TODAY Sports

The Yankees face a grueling reality with their batting order

As we evaluate the top half of the New York Yankees‘ batting order, it’s clear that stars like Aaron Judge […]
scott effross, yankees

Yankees eyeing key bullpen reinforcement with rehab assignment underway

The New York Yankees‘ bullpen has faced several challenges recently, leading pitching coach Matt Blake to initiate significant changes. In […]
MLB: Spring Training-Atlanta Braves at New York Yankees
Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-USA TODAY Sports

Yankees castaway bullpen arm signs with AL East rival, young arm flashes quality

The New York Yankees‘ bullpen, while currently ranking 5th in MLB with a commendable 3.39 ERA, has faced significant challenges […]
MLB: New York Yankees at Kansas City Royals
Credit: Denny Medley-USA TODAY Sports

The Yankees need their former All-Star to step up now

As the season progresses, former All-Star Gleyber Torres finds his prospects for a long-term contract with the New York Yankees […]
MLB: Baltimore Orioles at New York Yankees
Credit: John Jones-USA TODAY Sports

Did the Yankees find their long-term solution at first base?

The New York Yankees have encountered a significant setback with Anthony Rizzo sidelined due to a fracture in his right […]
MLB: Game One-Oakland Athletics at Minnesota Twins
Credit: Matt Krohn-USA TODAY Sports

The Yankees could get a much-needed infield punch from new infield bat

Before their Sunday loss to the Atlanta Braves, the New York Yankees completed a trade with the Oakland Athletics for […]
MLB: Baltimore Orioles at New York Yankees
Credit: Vincent Carchietta-USA TODAY Sports

Yankees lose key slugger for a minimum of 4 weeks

The New York Yankees bolstered their infield on Sunday by acquiring J.D. Davis, who is expected to see time at […]
MLB: Game One-Oakland Athletics at Minnesota Twins, yankees
Credit: Matt Krohn-USA TODAY Sports

Yankees acquire veteran utility man from Athletics to reinforce roster

In response to pressing needs within the infield, New York Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman actively sought solutions over the […]
MLB: New York Yankees at San Diego Padres
Credit: David Frerker-USA TODAY Sports

The Yankees’ batting order just got blended

Despite having power hitters like Aaron Judge and Juan Soto, the New York Yankees‘ lineup has faced significant setbacks in […]

Josh Donaldson’s check needs to bounce, or maybe it’s him that should bounce:

The only reason this is a problem is because Cashman and the organization actively went out and acquired him, as well as IKF — who is no picnic to watch play, either — and agreed to take on Donaldson’s entire contract. That meant that JD was to be paid $23 million last season, and this year he’s set to take home another $21 million.

The Yanks basically said no to any of the big-name SS that have been on the market the past two off-seasons, partially due to the fact that they have so much money allocated to JD. The biggest gripe I take away from the transaction itself is that if the Yankees really wanted to part ways with Gary Sanchez that badly, why not just have DFA’d him and held onto Gio? Urshela, now an Angel, was objectively better than Donaldson last season.

Donaldson making as much money as he is makes it very difficult to offload him, and unlike Uncle Steve in Queens, Cashman and co don’t seem anxious to cut their losses and trim the fat. Though Donaldson was making far more money than he should’ve been, he was fortunately still very reliable on the defensive side. He posted 7 DRS and 7 OAA, both bests since his 2019 resurgence of a year with the Braves. He was slick, smooth, and able to cover exceptional amounts of ground at third base, despite being the least athletic guy out there.

However, despite the defensive stalwart that he is, it doesn’t make up for robbing the organization of nearly $50 million for two years’ worth. Even with him being one of the best defensive third baseman in the league, he still posted just a 1.6 fWAR over 132 games.

For reference, 1.0 WAR is worth roughly $8 million, according to Fangraphs, so JD should’ve been getting paid roughly $12 million or so last season for his efforts, yet he made double that. He was paid $23 million to swing and miss at a career-worst clip and watch pitches down the middle more than he ever had.

For the first time since 2010, when he made his debut, he posted negative runs according to BaseballSavant’s Swing/Take Runs. He posted -2 across the board this year and paired that with career-worst in Meatball Swing % (which means he didn’t swing at gimme pitches) at 78.1% and 1st Pitch Swing % at 36.3%. He simply didn’t wait for his pitches, was far more aggressive than he needed to be at the plate, and didn’t jump on the mistakes.

Donaldson ranked in the bottom 8% of the entire league for Whiff Rate this season, and he posted the second-lowest Hard Hit % since 2015, at just 43.2% — which was down from 53% the two years prior. Simply put, he was just putrid with the bat in his hands.

If he’s on the Yankees’ roster in ’23, maybe there’s still something left in the tank:

The one main saving grace to his atrocious 2022 campaign is that it can’t possibly get any worse than that, right? The biggest thing with Donaldson is that there are clearly tools there that make up a fantastic hitter, and that was evident for a few years there when he was toe-to-toe with Mike Trout for the most valuable player in baseball.

The other intriguing thing is that in Donaldson’s career, for the past four years, he’s gone off and on with his Barrel % and that usually correlates with his performance. What I mean by that is in ’18, he barreled up only 8.2% of balls, and in ’19, it was up to 15.2%. Then, in the shortened 2020 year, it went back down to 6.9% before skyrocketing up to 17.4% the following season. This year, he only barreled up 9.8% of balls hit in play, and if the recent trajectory shows anything, next year should see a large spike, in theory at least.

Though, the most likely situation for Donaldson does look to be a platoon at 3B and getting occasional DH days when, and if, Stanton is deployed in the outfield. He can still make a difference on this team if some things go his way and if he reverts back to what made him so successful in the past.

Donaldson has always been a guy that is very passionate about his craft and is constantly in the lab trying to work out the kinks in his swing and approach. This last season was a career-worst for him, and if he wants to have any chance at saving face with the fans of this franchise, he needs to rebound in a big way. Nobody knows exactly what Boone and co. are thinking when it comes to what the OD lineup will be a few months from now, but if JD is still in Pinstripes, he has to do more than he did last year.

There’s simply no way the team can continue to throw him out there and have him bat anywhere in the middle of the lineup; I don’t care what his pedigree indicates.

Sadly, Father Time always gets the best of us in the end, and the light may be dwindling on his career. If he wants any shot at continuing to play baseball at a high level, he has to make changes. He cannot watch hittable pitches down the middle of the plate and then proceed to swing at a slider down and away. Last year, JD saw an astonishing 502 pitches low and away, out of the strike zone, and he chased those pitches at an astronomically high rate. If he wants to turn back the clock for one last hoorah, he has to be more disciplined.

For a guy who walked at least 10% of the time every single year since 2013, the sub-10% clip he posted last season (even just barely at 9.9%) should spark a fire inside of him. Pair that with the worst K% of the 2010s and 2020s for his fantastic career at 27.1%, and there has to be some motivation to improve. I know not everyone is a fan of the Bringer of Rain, but that’s because he brought us nothing but pain 90% of the time last year. If he is able to flip the script and post-JD-esque numbers as he did in years past, then perhaps he’ll have a big role on this team after all.

Mentioned in this article:

More about: