The Yankees are heading into spring training without a clear answer at third base, and if nothing changes, they may have to roll with Oswaldo Cabrera as their best available option.
General manager Brian Cashman has already listed Cabrera, DJ LeMahieu, and Oswald Peraza as the three internal candidates for the position, but none of them offer the kind of stability or upside the team would prefer at the hot corner.
LeMahieu’s Decline Creates a Glaring Hole
DJ LeMahieu had been a staple in the Yankees’ infield, but he’s not the same player he once was. His offense has taken a significant hit over the past two seasons, and while his defensive ability remains solid, the Yankees need more than just a glove at third base.
In 2024, LeMahieu slashed .204/.269/.259 over 67 games, managing just two home runs and 26 RBIs. That kind of production isn’t going to cut it, especially for a team trying to run back a World Series appearance.
Peraza’s Unproven Bat Makes Him a Risk
Oswald Peraza brings defensive upside, but his offensive game is still a massive question mark. The 23-year-old has yet to establish himself as a reliable big-league hitter, and while his glove could be a plus, the Yankees don’t have the luxury of carrying an everyday infielder who struggles to make an impact at the plate. Given the team’s championship aspirations, banking on Peraza to suddenly figure things out offensively is a major gamble.
Cabrera: The Last Resort That Might Be the Best Option
Cabrera may not be the perfect solution, but he might be the safest choice out of the three. He’s at least shown the ability to sport a decent batting average and provides some value with his switch-hitting ability. While he doesn’t walk much, he makes contact consistently and can leverage Yankee Stadium’s short right porch as a left-handed hitter.
Last season, Cabrera slashed .247/.296/.365 over 109 games, hitting seven home runs with 39 RBIs. His 88 wRC+ suggests he was 12% below average offensively, but compared to LeMahieu’s steep regression and Peraza’s unknowns, he’s at least a steady presence.
The biggest issue is that Cabrera’s greatest strength is his versatility, not his bat. He’s a valuable player because he can fill in all over the field, and locking him into third base could limit the Yankees’ ability to use him elsewhere when injuries inevitably pile up.
Yankees relief pitcher dealing with vague back injury
Yankees: Good news and bad news after 7-7 tie vs. Rays
Yankees may have a future star pitcher under team control for 6 bargain years
Yankees’ ‘jacked’ infielder is demolishing his way into a roster spot
Yankees’ 2021 2nd Round pick looking strong in camp following surgery
Yankees’ surprise contender could sneak onto opening day roster
Yankees’ once promising prospect might finally get his promotion to the majors
Yankees’ veteran pitcher went from last resort to impact piece in just a week
Yankees’ star prospects mentioned as possible trade pieces to upgrade pitching
Yankees 6, Phillies 5: Good news and bad news from walkoff win
The Yankees Still Need a Better Answer
If the Yankees were simply looking for an average third baseman, Cabrera might be a fine placeholder. But this team isn’t aiming to be average—they’re trying to win a World Series. Running back Cabrera, LeMahieu, or Peraza at third base without a real upgrade feels like settling, and unless Cashman makes a move before Opening Day, the Yankees could be walking into a season with a glaring weakness at a critical position.