The Yankees must keep Miguel Andujar for one significant reason

New York Yankees, Miguel Andujar

Follow ESM On Social


With speculation that the Yankees will look to deal third baseman Miguel Andujar this offseason, it’s justifiable to analyze his value. Andujar is coming off a season on the injured list after a torn labrum, a serious injury that will require plenty of recovery time.

“I’m definitely getting a lot of interest in Miguel Andujar while I’m sitting down here,” Cashman told ESPN Radio on Wednesday while in Scottsdale, Ariz., for the MLB GM Meetings. “I’ve got clubs asking me, ‘What are you going to do with him? We’d have an interest in him. Mark us down.’”

The youth product’s value undoubtedly took a hit from his spell on the injured list, and that’s the primary reason general manager Brian Cashman shouldn’t consider trading him away. Allowing him to return and show he can replicate his rookie season is the ideal scenario for the Yankees.

Best case scenario, Andujar develops into the team’s everyday third baseman, and worst case, he can be used as trade bait next offseason with a full-campaign of productivity and statistics under his belt. This will give Cashman more value to work with and allow him to pursue other top players.

The Yankees can expand on Andujar’s value:

From an objectional standpoint, Andujar’s cost isn’t only low because of his injury, but Gio Urshela also factors in. Urshela resembles a regular starter on the hot-corner for the Bombers, and that lowers Miguel’s value as well. Teams know the Yankees don’t necessarily need Andujar and will utilize that reality to drive down his price.

With Andujar’s defensive struggles playing a part, Cashman mentioned the idea of moving him around in the infield to test different scenarios. This could be a good idea, but the Yankees have answers at nearly every position. Shortstop is filled with Gleyber Torres or a free agent, DJ LeMahieu houses second base, and first base will likely rotate between Luke Voit and Mike Ford.

Third base is the only realistic option for Andujar, and that’s where he should continue to develop. However, Urshela’s defensive prowess places significant value on his head, but that shouldn’t deter Cashman from holding onto Andujar for at least one more season in an attempt to increase his value. If his bat comes to life next year, the trade deadline could be an excellent place to start shopping.

Like this article?

Never Miss a Post!

Subscribe and get notified everytime we publish new content.

1 thought on “The Yankees must keep Miguel Andujar for one significant reason”

  1. “…Shortstop is filled with Gleyber Torres or a free agent, DJ LeMahieu houses second base…”

    Trying Andujar at second base or shortstop still keeps his erratic arm and footwork in play, doesn’t it? And we’ve already established the fact that Urshela’s air-tight defense and stellar clutch hitting (especially with two outs and two strikes) are more than enough to justify penciling him as the everyday third baseman. Your conclusion that Miguel has nowhere else to go is short-sighted. Ford and Voit can just as easily be dangled as trade bait as Clint Frazier which would make first base or a corner outfield spot available to Andujar. Personally I think that would make a lot more sense for Andujar and the Yanks–particularly if you put him at first base where a lot less throwing would be required…

    24 year old hitters who can hit .300 and drive in 100 or more RBI’s don’t grow on trees. And I’m not convinced Voit or Ford have the skill to produce at the plate the way Andujar can overall…

    My Three cents…

    Sta. Monica

Leave a comment!