Yankees’ plans to evaluate the front office was a complete fallacy

MLB: New York Yankees-Aaron Judge press conference
Jessica Alcheh-USA TODAY Sports

When Hal Steinbrenner, the New York Yankees owner, announced the idea to bring in a third-party evaluator for the front office, many fans expected a deep dive into the challenges that plagued the team in 2023. Contrary to this belief, Andy Martino of SNY presents a different story.

Rather than an introspective analysis to pinpoint weaknesses, the Yankees seem to be taking an external comparison route. The goal? To juxtapose their analytical model with another firm’s, potentially leading them to reaffirm their current strategies. This could mean sticking to the very decisions that have, in many eyes, set the team on a challenging path.

Diving Deeper
“Here is what is actually happening, according to those four sources: The Yankees will be paying to view how an outside firm runs analytics, and then comparing it to the way they operate in that area. It is a self-evaluation, because they are looking at another company, rather than having a company look at them. The front office has been considering this opportunity for several years, and has now received clearance to spend the money.”

Yankees’ Past Decisions Under Scrutiny

Noteworthy moves, such as the acquisition of Josh Donaldson and the more recent signing of Carlos Rodon, are indicators of the Yankees’ strategy. This preference for talent that has previously battled injuries has left the team in a tight spot. The situation with Frankie Montas, who missed nearly all of the 2023 season, further underscores the need for recalibration. Presently, the focus appears to be shifting towards nurturing prospects and making strategic acquisitions.

Looking Ahead

Trade rumors suggest the Yankees might be on the prowl for some powerful bats, potentially tapping into Rule 5 draft-eligible prospects. With a budget of around $55 million for free agency, General Manager Brian Cashman has the resources to eye standout talents like Yoshinobu Yamamoto, the 25-year-old pitching sensation from Japan.

While a return to form is on the horizon for the Yankees, it seems an overhaul of their front-office strategies was misinterpreted. The unwavering trust in Cashman’s decisions remains a hallmark of the team’s approach.

Martino points out an interesting strategy mix adopted by the Yankees. Unlike teams heavily leaning on modern analytics, the Yankees attempt to merge traditional baseball wisdom with cutting-edge data. But the big question lingers: Will this blend pave the way for their much-coveted World Series win in 2024, or does the formula need further tweaking?

Mentioned in this article:

More about: