Yankees’ Aaron Boone on the Hot Seat: Aaron Judge comes to his defense

mlb: new york yankees at atlanta braves, aaron boone
Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports

The New York Yankees are navigating through one of their gloomiest seasons in over a decade, with the fingers pointed at subpar roster assembly and less-than-stellar acquisitions. At the center of this maelstrom is General Manager Brian Cashman, the man with the most direct influence over these transactional decisions.

Hal Steinbrenner Intervenes at the Trade Deadline

Here’s the straightforward reality: Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner had to intervene at the trade deadline to prevent the team from digging an even deeper hole for itself. Cashman was already in talks with other general managers, considering prospective deals. However, Steinbrenner pulled the plug on any immediate actions, signaling that a serious off-season reevaluation is on the horizon. This is a clear indication that changes are imminent.

Speculations Around Manager Aaron Boone

Amid this turbulent period, rumors have begun to swirl around the Yankees’ managerial position currently occupied by Aaron Boone. But let’s clear the air: Boone is not the main issue here. The man isn’t the one engineering trades; he’s merely tasked with coaching the players handed to him by Cashman. And unfortunately, that roster is riddled with players who are not living up to expectations.

[su_posts template=”templates/list-loop.php” posts_per_page=”3″ tax_term=”1622326″ offset=”1″ order=”desc”]

Boone’s Limited Control Over Player Performance

It’s crucial to note that Boone can’t magically fix Giancarlo Stanton’s lackluster .201 batting average or his .281 OBP for the season. He also can’t prevent Aaron Judge from taking a literal run into a concrete wall. Certain variables, clearly out of Boone’s managerial control, shouldn’t be laid at his doorstep.

Roster Constraints

While Boone has made some questionable choices—particularly regarding pitching—he’s had to make do with players like Billy McKinney, Jake Bauers, and Greg Allen for the better part of the 2023 season. Consistently starting these players doesn’t exactly spell out “elite roster.”

Aaron Judge Supports Boone

When SNY’s Andy Martino asked Aaron Judge about Boone’s standing amidst these troubles, Judge was unwavering in his support, stating, “No,” (Judge) said. “I want to answer that. I’ve been with Boonie all the way since 2018. He’s the guy.”

The Fan Perspective: A Scapegoat is Needed

The uncomplicated truth is that the Yankees’ players respect Boone and stand by him. But the fans? They’re out for blood, and someone has to take the fall.

Yankees’ Current State of Affairs: What’s Next for Boone and Cashman?

As it stands, it seems Boone will continue at the helm, and Cashman will keep his GM seat warm. But don’t discount a significant shake-up in the analytics department, particularly given their role in constructing a flawed roster and investing in injury-prone talent.