When the New York Yankees parted ways with Marcus Stroman, it felt like a calculated gamble.
Instead of clinging to a veteran presence, they turned to youth—a decision that can feel like rolling dice in a hurricane.
But sometimes, the gamble pays off, and in the Yankees’ case, Cam Schlittler is proving exactly that.
The assumption among many fans and analysts was clear: youth equals inexperience, and inexperience leads to costly mistakes.
Yet baseball, like life, often rewards those willing to trust raw talent and nurture it. The Yankees saw something in Schlittler and fellow young arm Will Warren, believing their upside could match or even exceed Stroman’s output.
Cam Schlittler’s Early Impact
So far, that belief looks well-founded. Schlittler, just 24, has handled his transition to the majors with a calm maturity beyond his years.
In his latest start on Wednesday, he tossed five strong innings against the Minnesota Twins, allowing only one run on two hits and two walks while striking out six.
His performance lowered his season ERA to a crisp 3.94 over 29.2 innings—a number any rookie would proudly wear.
Manager Aaron Boone pulled him after 86 pitches, leaving fans wondering if one or two more outs were possible. But the decision wasn’t his to make, and the Yankees clearly prefer protecting his arm over pushing for extra outs in August.
A Track Record That Commands Respect
This isn’t some overnight success story. Before arriving in the Bronx, Schlittler carved up Double-A hitters with a 2.38 ERA before posting a solid 3.80 in Triple-A Columbus.
Those numbers convinced the Yankees he was ready for the bright lights. Since his call-up, Schlittler hasn’t flinched, showing poise even when facing deep, veteran lineups.
What makes his rise even more impressive is that he’s not yet close to his ceiling. His arsenal—featuring a triple-digit fastball, sharp curveball, cutter, and sinker—is still being refined.
Each pitch has the raw potential to dominate, but he’s still learning how to consistently harness that movement and sequencing.
Areas for Growth
For all the promise, Schlittler still has boxes to check before joining the American League’s elite. His six swings and misses on Wednesday show he’s missing some of the deception or late life needed to rack up strikeouts at a higher clip.
And while his ERA looks strong, efficiency remains a hurdle—he’s yet to pitch six full innings in any of his six starts.
The good news? Those issues are coachable. Pitchers with his velocity and command foundation often take a year or two to truly master their craft.
Once Schlittler learns to sequence his pitches and induce more weak contact earlier in counts, the deeper outings will follow.
- Bold Gamble: Yankees might have found Luke Weaver 2.0
- The Yankees’ $90 Million Gamble: Is Michael King worth the massive price tag?
- Yankees News & Buzz: Rangers shut down Corey Seager speculation; Yanks keep flirting with the idea of adding Michael King, more
Outperforming Expectations—and Veterans
Even if he’s not dominating from start to finish yet, Schlittler is giving the Yankees exactly what they need: five competitive innings every time out.
In a season where veterans like Stroman, Carlos Carrasco, and Allan Winans have struggled to provide consistency in the back of the rotation, his stability feels like a fresh breeze on a muggy summer day.
He might not fully peak until 2025 or beyond, but right now, Schlittler is helping keep the Yankees in games they might otherwise lose.
And for a team chasing October, that’s as valuable as any marquee trade deadline acquisition.
READ MORE: Yankees’ $12.5 million infielder injured at the worst possible time
More about: New York Yankees
