Some seasons reveal surprises that don’t show up on preseason depth charts. The Giants are living that reality right now, discovering that one of their most dependable defensive sparks has come not from a draft pick or high-profile signing, but from a veteran backup who has quietly earned every snap he’s been given.
Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles wasn’t supposed to be a storyline this season. The Giants intended to groom 2024 sixth-round pick Darius Muasau behind Micah McFadden, gradually building him into a rotational linebacker with upside. Instead, injuries and inconsistencies forced the coaching staff to sift deeper into the roster. And that’s where they stumbled onto a player whose impact has grown sharper with each passing week.
Muasau struggled to stabilize the position, opening the door for change
The Giants gave Muasau every chance to seize the LB2 role early in the year. He played 307 snaps, showcased good energy, and flashed physicality at times. But the details weren’t there. His 18.8 percent missed tackle rate was alarming, his angles were often too aggressive, and his recovery speed wasn’t enough to compensate for lapses in space.
Add in the lingering injuries he’s been battling, and the Giants found themselves in a difficult position. They needed stability, not volatility, especially after McFadden went down in Week 1. That forced the staff to pivot — and it’s lucky they did.
Flannigan-Fowles brings effort, discipline, and consistency the defense needed
Flannigan-Fowles entered the league in 2019 as an undrafted free agent with the 49ers, spending five seasons learning one of the league’s most disciplined defensive systems. Those years hardened his instincts and taught him how to play within structure. That foundation is showing now.
Across his snaps this season, Flannigan-Fowles has recorded 15 tackles, two pressures, and has allowed 85 yards in coverage. On paper, those aren’t flashy metrics. But the eye test paints a much clearer picture. He plays fast. He rallies to the ball with urgency. His angles are crisp, his tackling technique is steady, and his communication has given the front seven more organization when the unit has needed it most.
Against the Green Bay Packers, his best game yet, he recorded five tackles and a pass defended — a small moment statistically, but a big one for a defense looking for someone to inject effort and consistency into a banged-up linebacker group.
Filling McFadden’s void is no small task, but Flannigan-Fowles has handled it admirably
McFadden was a major loss. His instincts, downhill aggressiveness, and ability to trigger quickly against the run made him one of the Giants’ best young defenders before his long-term injury. Replacing that profile is almost impossible for a reserve player.
Yet Flannigan-Fowles hasn’t tried to be McFadden. He’s brought his own brand of reliable, steady-handed football — and that’s exactly what this defense needed. His effort level has stood out on film. His communication has helped keep fronts aligned. And his urgency has elevated the energy of the entire linebacker room.
He’s not a star, but he’s a professional — and sometimes that matters more than anything else.
A role worth preserving as the Giants look toward next season
McFadden will return healthy in 2026 and reclaim the starting job. That much is clear. But what Flannigan-Fowles has shown down the stretch should make the Giants think long and hard about keeping him as a core reserve.
Depth matters in the NFL, especially at a position as physically demanding as linebacker. And the Giants have learned the hard way how quickly injuries can thin that room.
Flannigan-Fowles has proven he belongs. He’s shown the consistency Muasau lacked, the discipline that’s hard to teach, and the effort that keeps defenses functioning through adversity.
The Giants didn’t expect him to be part of their long-term plan. But after what he’s shown this season, it would be smart to make sure he is.
More about: New York Giants
