New York Giants Change Mind On Waiving B.J. Goodson, Trade Him Instead

New York Giants linebacker, B.J. Goodson.

In a strange turn of events, it looks like B.J. Goodson isn’t going to be waived by the Giants after all. The player was supposedly going to be waived following the end of the preseason, where other players managed to stand out more at the linebacker position and unseat the veteran who ha started for the past couple of years with the Giants, but a late offer from the Packers will allow the team to get something for Goodson instead of letting him go for nothing.

The terms of the deal haven’t been reported yet, but the trade definitely doesn’t include another player – it’s more likely a draft pick in the lower rounds.

Goodson, a product of the Clemson Tigers, was drafted in the fourth round in 2016 by the Giants and has played with the team until this trade, becoming a regular player on defense and a starter within the Giants’ group of linebackers. Linebacker play, though, hasn’t been one of the strongest points in recent seasons and Goodson found himself falling behind enough that before the Packers offered a trade, the team intended to move on from Goodson entirely by waiving him.

With the new roster space, the Giants have signed former Dave Gettleman draft pick David Mayo, who was taken in the fifth round by the Carolina Panthers in 2015 and played with the team up until 2019 when Mayo became a free agent and signed with the 49ers before being released during the team’s final cuts. Mayo played in all 16 games last season for the Panthers and started three of them, registering 14 total tackles during the regular season.

Time will tell whether or not Mayo is good enough to stay on the team and get in the rotation, but the signing can’t hurt – and the Giants will be happy to get something in return for Goodson, a player they were intending to let go for nothing.

New York Giants waive veteran linebacker BJ Goodson, two potential signings

New York Giants linebacker, B.J. Goodson.

The New York Giants waived veteran linebacker BJ Goodson on Monday morning, which could be a pre-disposed move indicating a potential signing in the near future.

With several quality linebackers on the free-agent market, Goodson became expendable. The former Clemson product simply didn’t fit in defensive coordinators James Bettcher’s system, as he is a bigger linebacker that lacks elite athleticism.

Bettcher prefers linebackers that can fly around the field and play close to the line of scrimmage and drop back in coverage.

In addition, Goodson has been injured over the course of his three-year career with the Giants. He played in 15 games, starting 13 of them in 2018. He racked up 61 combined tackles and three quarterback hits. In 2017, he started just seven games before leaving with injury. He is a quality linebacker against the run and plays well close to the line of scrimmage, but has difficulty dropping him back into coverage. He’s essentially a poor man’s Alec Ogletree.

Here are two linebackers the New York Giants could sign:

There are two specific linebackers on the market that could be of interest to the Giants and general manager Dave Gettleman. Former Oakland Raiders linebacker Brandon Marshall could be an option. He recently stated that he used training camp with the Raiders to get back to full health after suffering a serious knee injury last season.

Marshall could be a perfect fit with the Giants, as he is one of the best coverage linebackers in football, according to Raiders coach Jon Gruden. While he might be a bit more expensive, he certainly has the attributes to be a key contributor if signed to the defense.

The second option is former Denver Broncos linebacker, Shane Ray. The former first-round pick has struggled in the NFL up to this point. However, in 2016 he recorded eight sacks and 48 combined tackles. He is fast at the line of scrimmage and can wreak havoc on opposing quarterbacks. Finding a way to extract his potential in value is the hard part given his lack of productivity in recent years. He would likely be cheaper than Marshall, but his production would not be as valuable.

New York Giants News, 8/31 – Giants could sign quality veteran linebacker

Could the New York Giants consider free agent, Brandon Marshall?

Good Morning, New York Giants Fans!

The Giants’ defense is all but settled when it comes to the sure-fire starters; however, there aren’t many plug-and-play options that have enough talent to succeed at the top level. With roster cuts going down on Saturday, team’s have already begun trimming, leaving quality players to find new clubs.

One of the more recent cuts, linebacker Brandon Marshall, could fit perfectly with the Giants. Coming off a knee injury, Marshall must prove he’s capable of operating at a high level, as he once did with the Denver Broncos. Raiders coach Jon Gruden called Marshall “one of the best coverage linebackers in football.”

With the emergence of Marshall on the free-agent market, it could force the Giants to cut veteran BJ Goodson in favor of the cover linebacker.

Marshall used training camp to return to full health, as he was unable to feature during the preseason. That might have hurt his chances to start right away for the Raiders, but he could be an impactful force for a different team. The Giants are extremely thin at the linebacker position and need to inject more quality to supplement potential injury and deficiencies. On a team-friendly deal, Marshall could fit the bill perfectly.


Paul Schwartz (NY Post) – Giants could have interest in released linebacker Brandon Marshall

Ed Valentine (Big Blue View) – Giants roster cuts tracker: Follow all the roster moves here

New York Giants veteran linebacker saves job with one massive play

New York Giants, B.J. Goodson

While the New York Giants finished off the preseason 4-0 with a victory against the New England Patriots on Thursday night, linebacker BJ Goodson certainly elevated his game.

The veteran linebacker was a fringe-roster player before the matchup but proved he can still be a productive player on the defense with five tackles and one sack in just the first quarter of the game.

Defensive coordinator James Bettcher prefers more athletic linebackers that have better instinctual attributes, as Goodson is a slower linebacker that can sometimes take longer to get to the ball-carrier than preferred. However, he made one stellar play against the Pats that might have saved him from being cut.

Some believed that Nate Stupar would earn the nod ahead of Goodson when it came to roster cuts, but it’s becoming clear that both can stick and serve a purpose next season. The experience the Clemson product brings to the defense and the familiarity with Bettcher’s scheme can’t be replaced, despite a faster, more flexible option being more ideal.

On the play above, Goodson shoots through the gap untouched for the sack. He put on the after-burners and reached the quarterback to force a second-and-long play that ultimately led to a punt.

Who else is fighting for playing time on the New York Giants?

The only other legitimate competition at the linebacker position is rookie, Ryan Connelly. The Wisconsin product has made waves this preseason with his quickness and ability to shoot gaps with precision. It will take time for him to adapt to the speed and physicality of the NFL, especially with a lack of size, but he can develop into a quality player that starts regular on the defense.

I anticipate Connelly acting as the reserve option behind Tae Davis (money-backer), due to his ability to operate in coverage but also play close to the line of scrimmage.

New York Giants: Five Players Who Will Be Hard To Release

T.J. Jones, New York Giants

In 2018 the New York Giants turned over so much of their roster they didn’t have many difficult decisions to make. Fast-forward one year and there are some very tough decisions now that the roster is improving under new GM Dave Gettleman. Here are 5 players who would be very tough to say goodbye to:

BJ Goodson

The inside linebacker hasn’t been super impressive in his career, now going into his fourth season. While he’s left a lot to be desired he’s a step above the available inside linebackers on the market. BJ Goodson will most likely be picked up by another team quickly, but he hasn’t out-produced his in-house competition in Tae Davis and Ryan Connelly.

If the team doesn’t plan on keeping four inside linebackers, which is a tall task, they will be forced to release BJ Goodson. Keeping an extra inside linebacker would be a luxury for a team who has uncertainty at the position but the team most likely won’t have room for luxuries.

Scott Simonson

Scott Simonson has been a blocking specialist for the Oakland Raiders, Carolina Panthers, and most recently, the New York Giants in 2018. Before last year he caught 1 pass in his first 3 years but caught 9 passes from Eli in 2018. He proved to be a functional pass catcher when given the opportunity, along with adequate blocking ability, but the team has plenty of depth at this position.

Evan Engram and Rhett Ellison are a lock to make the team, leaving one more spot for a tight end. Simonson faces tough competition in Garrett Dickerson and CJ Conrad who have both looked more impressive than Simonson throughout training camp. There’s a chance the coaching staff feels differently about his summer performance and keeps Simonson, but if they do move on from him, it will not be an easy decision.

Bennie Fowler

This may surprise some people since Bennie Fowler has been running with the first-team throughout the summer. While that’s true, guys like Sterling Shepard, Golden Tate, and Darius Slayton have all missed significant amounts of practices. Fowler suited up for the New York Giants for 10 games last year, but the team has a ton of depth at this position going into 2019.

Not to say the position has improved overall without you know who, but the depth of the position looks much stronger compared to last year. Fowler started his career as a Denver Bronco and was a backup receiver for the team. He never broke 400 receiving yards and his average yardage per reception never even reached 9 yards.

One of the major knocks on Fowler is the dropped passes which have been an issue here an there this summer. Fowler’s combination of size and speed is impressive but there are too many sure-handed receivers to pick from on the roster to trust Fowler going into a new season.

Brittan Golden

Brittan Golden was injured for most of the training camp but his recent performance should make the coaching staff take a 2nd look at him. After seeming destined to be axed this Saturday, he took the field against the Bengals and returned a punt 68 yards for a touchdown. That’s a skill the team has been seeking for a long time. But for Golden to make the roster, the team would need to be willing to designate an entire roster spot to a return specialist.

Golden did catch a nice pass from Daniel Jones about 30 yards down the field, but the top three receiving spots have been decided already. He would also have guys like Darius Slayton, Russell Shepard, and Alonzo Russell to compete with for targets. Golden probably got healthy too late in the summer to make a name for himself. If Jabrill Peppers is gassed after playing defense more often than not and Golden Tate’s age starts to dull his explosiveness, the team might wonder what could’ve been with the potential return specialist.

TJ Jones

Another wide receiver who has flashed throughout the preseason will probably be sent packing on Saturday. TJ Jones was added to the team after camp already started, but he’s done well enough to possibly carve out a spot on the roster. The problem is, he’s not the only one.

One of the deepest positions on the roster is at wide receiver and there’s a handful who have guaranteed spots. Sterling Shepard, Golden Tate, Cody Latimer, and Darius Slayton will all be on the team. Only leaving 2 more spots for guys like Russell Shepard, Alonzo Russell, Bennie Fowler, Brittan Golden, and TJ Jones.

The team is very likely to keep Russell Shepard, giving the team 3 receivers who are primarily slot-receivers. This would make it hard to keep a fourth slot-receiver in TJ jones instead of an outside receiver. While he has the talent to stick on rosters around the league, the Giants have no shortage of slot-receiver talent.

This coming Saturday is oftentimes a coach’s most dreaded weekend of the year. Sometimes they have to send valuable players packing for one reason or another. The Giants have a few positions where they will need to shed adequate depth which isn’t easy to do. While it’s not always easy, it’ll be much harder to do than last year, indicating improvement of the team overall.

New York Giants News, 8/29 – Giants could pursue veteran linebacker

Should the New York Giants kick the tires on Malcolm Smith?

Good Morning, New York Giants Fans!

The Giants are extremely thin at the linebacker position, which is why kicking the tires on recently cut San Francisco 49er Malcolm Smith might not be a bad idea.

The seven-year veteran is preparing to hit the free agency market after a 2018 season plagued with injuries. The Giants could theoretically swoop in and grab him off the market after Saturday’s roster cut deadline.

Smith is a productive linebacker in the tackles category, breaking the 100 mark (combined) twice in the last three years. As a middle linebacker in 2015, he recorded four sacks, which shows he can be used in a diverse manner and close to the line of scrimmage.

Given that’s quite some time ago, it’s fair to say he has lost a step or two. Injuries have also surely taken their toll, but he can be a capable defender given the opportunity. The Giants currently house Alec Ogletree, rookie Ryan Connelly, and the potential cut-candidate, BJ Goodson. Tae Davis is also sprinkled in there as a “Money-Backer,” a term coined by defensive coordinator, James Bettcher.

Adding a quality linebacker with experience could be a boost to the unit’s productivity in 2019; however, it all comes down to his price-tag.


Your top news of the day!

Paul Schwartz (NY POST) – Cowboys are fearing the worst watching Giants’ Daniel Jones

Ed Valentine (Big Blue View) – What should the Giants do with Sam Beal?

John Fennelly (Giants Wire) – Corey Ballentine’s gunshot wound was ‘worse than what people thought’

Jordan Raanan (ESPN) – Giants’ 53-man roster projection includes Rod Smith, Kyle Lauletta

Alexander Wilson (Empire Sports Media) – New York Giants: Surprise undrafted defender could replace BJ Goodson

New York Giants News, 8/28 – One big surprising roster cut candidate

New York Giants linebacker, B.J. Goodson.

Good Morning, New York Giants Fans!

The reality of the Giants’ defense is simple — they’re unproven and young. The youthful part is a good thing, but it will take some time for them to adjust to the level of play in the NFL.

Surprisingly enough, it seems as if several rookies have already begun to elevate their game, ask Wisoncon product, Ryan Connelly. The former Badger has already stolen veteran BJ Goodson’s spot on the defense, considering he’s been working with the second and third-string defensive units.

Alec Ogletree and Tae Davis will slide into their normal starting roles, but Goodson will be left for the dogs if he doesn’t make an impact against the New England Patriots in the Giants’ final preseason game of the year on Thursday. He could be a prominent cut candidate once the Giants slim down their roster to the final 53-men on Saturday.

A large portion of the team will dissipate once cuts go down, but Goodson seems to be on his way out. Despite tallying 61 combined tackles and two interceptions last season, he’s not shown improvement, which the Giants desperately need at the linebacker position. Connelly has provided more optimism so far this offseason.


Your top news of the day!

Tom Canavan (Yahoo! News) – Giants’ Paul Perkins on bubble after season lost to injury

John Fennelly (Giants Wire) – Giants have more dead money than cap space available

Ed Valentine (Big Blue View) – Giants’ roster battles: UDFAs with the best chance to make the 53-man roster

George Willis (NY Post) – Giants’ Jabrill Peppers was made for this: Crazy cleats, loudmouth

Alexander Wilson (Empire Sports Media) – New York Giants: 3 surprise roster cut candidates

New York Giants: 3 surprise roster cut candidates

New York Giants linebacker, B.J. Goodson.

The New York Giants are inching closer to their final preseason game of the year against the New England Patriots. While that’s a great thing for fans patiently waiting for the start of the regular season, fringe-roster players are still playing for their livelihoods.

Here are three surprise cuts for the New York Giants:

1.) CB Sam Beal

The Giants’ Supplemental Draft pick from 2018 has yet to play in a regular-season game let alone a preseason matchup this year. He missed all of his rookie season with a predisposed shoulder injury that required surgery. Now that his shoulder is healed, his hamstring has been acting up.

His lack of experience in a live-action setting could force the Giants to cut him and allocate the roster spot towards a player with actual, proven value. This would undoubtedly be a surprise but justifiable.

2.) LB B.J. Goodson

At this point in Goodson’s career, he seems to be losing value with every passing day. Injuries have hurt his development and consistency, and Ryan Connelly, the rookie out of Wisconsin, has taken full advantage of that.

Connelly has been working with the starting team in the absence of Alec Ogletree, and Goodson has been seeing time with the second and third-string defense. His influence last year isn’t noteworthy, and it seems as if his time as a Giant could be coming to an end. The only reason head coach Pat Shurmur would keep him around is because of the lack of depth at the linebacker position and his familiarity with DC James Bettcher’s scheme.

3.) RB Paul Perkins

With 546-yards rushing to his name, Perkins is a glorified scat-back. His minimal power and high injury risk make him a waste of a roster spot. This might not be a surprise cut, but his value is next to none on a Giants team with plenty of talent at the running back position.

Behind Saquon Barkley and Wayne Gallman, Perkins and Rod Smith have been battling it out for a third-string roster spot. Smith is the more wise choice that can help Gallman and Barkley refine the mental aspects of their game, which makes him a more valuable option.

Perkins once had a ton of potential, but his production would come from the passing game, and the Giants don’t need him with Barkley and Gallman more than capable of succeeding in that facet.

New York Giants: Ryan Connelly just booted BJ Goodson out of his spot

New York Giants, Ryan Connelly

The New York Giants have struggled at the linebacker position for the past few years, but they may have found a solution in rookie Ryan Connelly out of Wisconsin.

The four-year linebacker in college enters the NFL as a fifth-round pick with light expectations on his shoulders. However, he is already making waves around Giants camp and during the preseason which elevated his status and made him a potential starter for the 2019 season.

He has seemingly developed very quickly during training camp, likely because he’s facing off against one of the NFL’s top running backs, Saquon Barkley.

Facing off against that quality of talent will help him develop his game and refine his skills to achieve success at the NFL level. Ultimately, if he can stop Saquon Barkley in the open field, he can stop any running back in the league. Connelly’s plan from the get-go was to earn the trust of his teammates and coaches by commanding the huddle and being a quality MIC linebacker. His job was to provide physicality and prove his development early on.

At this point, it seems that Ryan has completely pushed BJ Goodson out of the second starting linebacker position. It is quite fascinating, considering he managed to dethrone a multi-year starter in just one training camp. Additionally, injuries have played a part in his career, and he is questionable in coverage at times.

While Connelly is still growing into his new role, he’s a much better linebacker in coverage and is exceptionally instinctual in regards to shooting gaps and playing against the run.

On Friday night against the Chicago Bears, Connelly shot through the gap on a third-and-one running play, just barely missing the running back and falling short of making a big stop.

While he did miss the tackle, it showed his athleticism and ability to get into the backfield very quickly. It is exciting to see what he can do from the middle of the defense and what we should expect to see from him in the future. Missing a vital tackle against the Bears is part of the rookie learning curve, but that will slowly alleviate itself as he continues to earn more playing time and experience.

He has shown the coaching staff that he is tenacious player plenty of upside. That is all you can Asfoor for my fifth-round pick that is just getting used to the physicality and speed of the NFL.

“I think he’s shown us that he belongs on the field,” Giants coach Pat Shurmur said. “Like any young player, when somebody goes down ahead of you, you get in there and take advantage of the reps you have.”

New York Giants linebacker could steal playing time from BJ Goodson

New York Giants linebacker, Tae Davis.

The New York Giants don’t have the most versatile and exciting linebacker corps, but they have the appropriate players to help succeed to a degree.

With Alec Ogletree and BJ Goodson acting as the expected starting linebackers, it minimizes the opportunity for other options, however, Tae Davis, second-year defender out of Tennessee, could steal playing time from Goodson.

Davis, who’s a solid cover backer, is better suited in passing packages where he can pick up tight ends and running backs coming out of the backfield. In fact, it’s possible he even fills in or rotates with Ogletree in specific scenarios. I believe, though, he will replace Goodson given Alec’s five interceptions in 2018.

Last season, defensive coordinator James Bettcher played Davis more on third downs. The undrafted rookie played in 14 games last season, starting in four. He tallied 33 combined tackles, 2.0 sacks, and four quarterback hits. I anticipate his numbers will take a jump in 2019 due to his developing skill-set.

Tae’s influence could be significant given his proficiency against tight ends. Landon Collins and Ogletree were often designated the assignment of locking down TEs last season, and the Giants ranked near the bottom of the league in defending them. Finding a solution for that problem was a priority this offseason, and Davis could certainly be it.

[su_posts template=”templates/teaser-loop.php” posts_per_page=”3″ tax_term=”151323″ order=”desc”]

How can the New York Giants make the most of Davis’ abilities?

Alec Ogletree is better suited playing closer to the line of scrimmage and stopping the run. With that being said, it promotes the usage of Davis more frequently, allowing Ogletree to spy on the quarterback while his counter-part drops back into coverage. Having Alec play in coverage wasn’t ideal last season, as he often found himself playing out of position. His numbers tell a different story, but he struggled nonetheless.

Locking down the tight end position will contain opposing offenses in a way the Giants haven’t experienced in quite some time. If David can reach his potential, the defense could be in a good shape heading into 2019.