The New York Yankees were already reeling from a rough weekend against the Boston Red Sox when the gut punch landed.
It wasn’t just that they dropped two of three games in the Bronx — it was who helped hand them the loss.
Carlos Narvaez, once a quiet catcher prospect in the Yankees’ system, now wears a different shade of white in Boston.
And in Sunday’s 11–7 loss, Narvaez crushed a go-ahead three-run homer that felt like salt in a fresh wound.
A trade that’s looking worse with every swing
The Yankees shipped Narvaez to Boston in exchange for right-hander Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz, a 21-year-old pitching prospect.
Rodriguez-Cruz currently holds a 2.95 ERA at High-A Hudson Valley, showing promise but still far from the majors.
Narvaez, meanwhile, looks like a breakout star — and he’s doing it on one of the Yankees’ most hated rivals.
In 51 games this season, Narvaez is slashing .281/.359/.456 with six homers, 22 RBIs, and a 127 wRC+.
From organizational depth to Boston’s everyday threat
Narvaez always had solid framing skills, but his bat was never supposed to be this big of a threat.
Now he’s not only hitting, he’s one of Boston’s most productive players on both sides of the ball.
Defensively, he ranks second among MLB catchers with five catcher framing runs and a 45.2% strike rate.
He’s doing the things the Yankees have long prided themselves on — but now he’s doing it for the enemy.
The game that left fans shaking their heads
In the sixth inning of Sunday’s game, Narvaez sent a ball soaring over the left-field wall for a three-run homer.
That blast flipped a 3–2 Yankees lead into a 5–3 Red Sox advantage, and Boston never looked back after that.
It wasn’t just a big moment — it felt personal, especially given the narrative swirling around his development arc.
Watching him round the bases, Yankee fans could only wonder what might’ve been had he stayed in the Bronx.
Yankees catcher development remains strong — but this one hurts
The Yankees are known for their success developing catchers, with a strong emphasis on defense and game-calling.
That reputation remains intact, but Carlos Narvaez is the one that got away — and he’s proving it fast.
In a way, it’s like watching your old car win a drag race after trading it for a promising but untested engine.
The Yankees believe Rodriguez-Cruz can turn into something special — but Narvaez is already producing on the big stage.
READ MORE: Yankees might have a secret weapon stashed in Triple-A to help the bullpen
More about: New York Yankees
