Yankees insider makes important Randal Grichuk prediction

The Yankees didn’t sign a superstar this week. They signed a solution.

When news broke that the club added Randal Grichuk to a minor league deal with a spring training invite, the reaction wasn’t fireworks. It was more of a shrug. But this wasn’t about headlines. It was about hitting left-handed pitching, and if you regularly watch baseball, you know exactly why this matters.

Grichuk isn’t here to sell jerseys. He’s here to mash lefties and go sit down.

A Specialist Hiding in Plain Sight

Let’s be honest about who Grichuk is. At 34 years old, he’s not the guy who popped 31 homers for the Blue Jays back in 2019. He’s not even the 2024 version with the Arizona Diamondbacks, when he quietly posted a 139 wRC+ in the desert and looked reborn for a minute. Last season between Arizona and Kansas City, he stumbled to an 82 wRC+ over 293 plate appearances. That’s bench bat territory. Fringe roster stuff.

But baseball is about roles, not résumés.

For his career, Grichuk owns a 118 wRC+ against left-handed pitching. That’s not smoke and mirrors. That’s 10-plus seasons of consistent damage against southpaws. Yes, he only managed an 89 wRC+ versus lefties in 2025, but you don’t accidentally run into a career-long split like that. It’s a skill.

The Yankees’ current roster leans left. Heavily. And when October rolls around, do you know what you see? Elite left-handed starters and high-leverage lefty relievers coming at you in waves. Boston. Baltimore. Toronto. It’s the AL East. They stockpile them like canned goods before a storm.

Grichuk is the umbrella.

Why Joel Sherman Is Probably Right

Yankees insider Joel Sherman didn’t mince words when he said he expects Grichuk to make the Opening Day roster. That’s not speculation for clicks. It’s roster math.

The Yankees have been hunting for a right-handed bat for months. Not a star. A stabilizer. Someone who can start in left field against a tough lefty, hit sixth or seventh, and make the opposing manager think twice before rolling out that mid-game southpaw. That’s Grichuk’s lane.

And it’s a narrow one. But it’s real.

The team could be streaky and frustrating when a tough lefty is on the mound. Grichuk doesn’t fix everything, but he does help.

The Domino Effect on Jasson Domínguez

Here’s where it gets uncomfortable.

If Grichuk makes the roster, it likely means Jasson Domínguez opens the season in Triple-A. Brian Cashman already floated that possibility, and now it feels less like posturing and more like the plan. The Yankees don’t need Domínguez sitting on the bench playing twice a week. They need him playing every day, refining his reads in the outfield, tightening his approach.

Development isn’t linear. It’s messy.

Domínguez is the future. Grichuk is the present tense. And the Yankees, despite the hype cycles and prospect buzz, are trying to win now. That means plugging holes, even if the plug is 34 years old and coming off a down year.

There’s also a financial angle. A minor league deal means zero risk. If Grichuk shows up in Tampa and the bat looks slow, you shake hands and move on. If he’s driving fastballs into the left-center gap against live arms? He’s on the plane north.

It’s not romantic. It’s practical.