The race for Juan Soto is neck-and-neck, and the New York teams seem to be taking center stage. According to Mark Feinsand of MLB.com, executives and agents around the league are convinced that Soto’s free agency decision is down to just two teams: the Yankees and the Mets. While other teams, like the Red Sox, Blue Jays, and Dodgers, might still be in the mix, the belief is clear—Soto’s future likely lies in New York.
The Yankees’ Case for Soto
The Yankees have made no secret of their desire to keep Soto in pinstripes. After acquiring him at last year’s trade deadline, Soto didn’t just meet expectations—he crushed them. Playing 157 games for the Yankees in 2024, Soto slashed .288/.419/.569, setting a career-high with 41 home runs and driving in 109 RBIs. His 8.1 WAR and AL-best 180 wRC+ made him one of the most valuable players in baseball.
Beyond the numbers, Soto showed he could handle the spotlight of the Bronx, thriving in high-pressure situations and delivering clutch performances throughout the season. If Soto signs a long-term deal, the Yankees wouldn’t just be adding a superstar; they’d be securing their offensive anchor for the next decade-plus.
For the Yankees, keeping Soto is about more than just stats. It’s about sending a message that the Bronx is still the ultimate destination for baseball’s biggest stars. Managing partner Hal Steinbrenner has reportedly made Soto a priority, and the Yankees have even added opt-outs to their offer, showing flexibility to make the deal as player-friendly as possible.
The Mets’ Pitch to Soto
On the other side of the city, Steve Cohen and the Mets are lurking as the Yankees’ biggest competition. If there’s one thing Cohen has proven during his tenure as owner, it’s that he’s not afraid to spend big. The Mets see Soto as the type of player who can not only reshape their roster but also change the perception of the franchise.
The Mets had success last year rehabbing former Yankees ace Luis Severino, and they’re looking to build on that momentum with a splashy offseason. Landing Soto would immediately position the Mets as one of the favorites in the National League and give them a legitimate shot to dethrone the Braves in the NL East — who lost Ronald Acuna last year.
For Soto, the Mets offer a chance to be the face of a franchise on the rise, playing in a city that’s equally passionate about its baseball. While the Mets don’t have the same storied history as the Yankees, they do have something powerful: Steve Cohen’s wallet.
The Numbers Behind Soto’s Stardom
Soto’s value goes beyond his ability to crush baseballs. His elite plate discipline is unmatched, with a .419 on-base percentage that ranked second in the majors last season. He posted a walk rate of 18.1%, which was also near the top of the league, and his left-handed swing is tailor-made for Yankee Stadium’s short porch. In fact, Soto hit 27 of his 41 home runs last season to the opposite field, a skill that translated perfectly in the Bronx.
At just 26 years old, Soto is entering the prime of his career, and the team that lands him isn’t just getting a generational talent—they’re getting a player whose best days are still ahead of him.
A Two-Horse Race
While other teams like the Blue Jays and Dodgers might still technically be in the mix, the league-wide consensus is that this is a two-horse race. The Yankees have the history, the prestige, and the immediate fit. The Mets have the ambition, the financial power, and a hunger to dethrone their cross-town rivals.
As Soto narrows his options, the final decision looms large. Will he choose the bright lights of the Bronx or the big ambitions of Queens? One thing’s for sure—New York baseball is about to get a whole lot more interesting.
Stay tuned. The Soto sweepstakes aren’t just about signing a superstar; they’re about reshaping the future of baseball in the Big Apple.