The Yankees find themselves at a fascinating crossroads with the trade deadline just around the corner.
They’re trailing in the American League East but staring down glaring bullpen issues that could sabotage their October dreams.
That’s why backup catcher J.C. Escarra, who’s quietly become one of baseball’s premier defensive backstops, might be their most attractive trade chip.
General manager Brian Cashman knows fixing the relief corps is non-negotiable — and it may cost them a key piece.
Escarra’s defensive brilliance makes him uniquely valuable
Escarra, 30, is the type of player whose value goes beyond the obvious stat sheet numbers.
His .215/.312/.354 slash line won’t turn many heads, but his glove work certainly does.
Escarra ranks near the top of Major League Baseball in both strike rate and catcher framing runs.
Essentially, he steals strikes with his pitch presentation better than almost anyone in the game.
Those subtle advantages can be the difference between getting out of an inning and watching a two-run double sail into the gap.
Teams see a potential everyday starter in J.C. Escarra
What makes Escarra even more appealing is his contract situation — he’s in his first year of arbitration and is under affordable team control through 2030.
For a team looking to shore up its catching situation long-term, that’s gold.
Add in the fact he’s shown flashes of good power and exceptional plate discipline, and it’s easy to see why clubs would line up.
If someone’s willing to give Escarra everyday reps, he might blossom into one of the more quietly productive catchers in the league.
Yankees could pivot to Ben Rice for more offense
Dealing Escarra would push rookie Ben Rice into a much larger role, effectively handing him the keys as the primary backup catcher.
Rice isn’t the same defensive force, but his bat adds serious thunder.
Slotting Rice behind the plate more often would let the Yankees keep his offensive production in the lineup while maximizing roster flexibility.
It’s a classic tradeoff — lose some elite glove work, gain a bat that could turn games on a single swing.
- Yankees finally reveal full 2026 coaching staff
- Yankees reportedly moving heaven and earth to bring back star outfielder
- Yankees ‘not expected to be a threat’ to sign Mets’ elite free agent
Why a bullpen arm might justify the gamble
With the Yankees’ bullpen stretched thin, Cashman might see Escarra as the most expendable piece who could still fetch a legitimate return.
Trading him for a controllable reliever would shore up a weak spot and give the Yankees a better shot at surviving tight playoff games.
In a way, it’s like selling a prized lock for a sturdier front door — protecting the house matters more.
More about: New York Yankees
