Not every team can survive losing a generational superstar.
But somehow, the New York Yankees haven’t just survived after Juan Soto’s departure—they’ve recalibrated and might actually be more balanced than ever.
Now, they prepare for the first Subway Series of the season, a high-stakes showdown against Soto and the Mets, who handed him a $765 million megadeal that could balloon to over $800 million.
This time, though, the Yankees aren’t looking back. They’re coming in with purpose—and plenty of punch.
Pitching depth tested, but still thriving
Coming into the season, the Yankees’ rotation was projected to be among the league’s best.
Max Fried, their $214 million ace, has pitched like the contract was a bargain. But they’ve also endured setbacks.
Gerrit Cole’s injury threw a wrench into their plans, and Luis Gil and Clarke Schmidt have each spent time on the sidelines — Gil is still out.
Despite the turbulence, the Yankees still hold the top spot in the American League East. Their ability to weather adversity has defined the early-season stretch.
Offense firing on all cylinders
Even with Cody Bellinger’s sluggish start, the Yankees lead baseball in several key offensive categories.
Bellinger, acquired from the Cubs and owed $25 million, is heating up just in time.
He’s hitting .229/.299/.389 with five homers and a .688 OPS, but over the past two weeks, those numbers have steadily climbed.
Then there’s Paul Goldschmidt.
Signed on a one-year, $12.5 million deal to plug the gap at first base, the veteran slugger is turning back the clock.
His bat has been invaluable, adding stability and experience to a lineup that’s already feared.
It’s no longer about a single star carrying the team—it’s about collective firepower.
Soto’s return, and a glimpse at what could have been
All eyes will be on Soto as he walks into Yankee Stadium wearing blue and orange instead of pinstripes.
He’s off to a solid start for the Mets, hitting .255/.380/.465 with eight home runs and a 140 wRC+. Still elite, still dangerous.
But the Yankees’ decision not to commit over $800 million might not be a loss after all.
With plans to pursue Kyle Tucker in next year’s free agency, the Yankees could land a Gold Glove-caliber outfielder with elite offensive upside—possibly for nearly half the price.
Tucker, one of the league’s most well-rounded players, might be the Yankees’ next big swing.
A defining series with long-term stakes
This Subway Series isn’t just a two-game spectacle—it’s a referendum on two diverging strategies.
The Mets bought the biggest bat on the market. The Yankees built a complete roster with financial flexibility and unexpected heroes.
And the results? New York’s AL team is still sitting comfortably atop the standings. However, the Mets are equally as dominant.
Come October, maybe the two sides meet in the World Series.
Popular Reading
Yankees’ injured reliever takes another step forward in rehab assignment