New York Yankee Player Profiles: Turning 30 today, will Gerrit Cole be an ace or a Yankee bust??

Gerrit Cole, New York Yankees
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit

New York Yankees general partner and owner Hal Steinbrenner spent $324 million on, to see Gerrit Cole in a Yankee uniform and pitching for the Yankees, at Yankee Stadium. Cole, 30, was born on September 8, 1990, in Newport Beach, California to Mark and Karen Cole. Cole’s father was from New York and a Yankee fan. His father would tell him stories of Lou Gehrig and other famous Yankees, and the young boy would quickly become a baseball fan and Yankee fanatic.

On weekends one could see the young boy playing baseball at local ball fields, playing any position, just so he could play. His father certainly nurtured Cole’s interest in the Yankees by flying him across the country seven times to Yankee Stadium, so he could see his idols, Mariano Rivera, Derek Jeter, and Andy Pettitte. Cole was a member of the Tustin Western Little League team of Newport Beach.

In 2001 hiS Dad would take the young Cole to the World Series in Arizona so he could see his favorite Yankees play. The eleven-year-old could be seen in the stands with a Yankee uniform and cap on, while holding a sign saying “Yankee Fan Today, Tomorrow, Forever”. Being a life long Yankee fan had to, in some way sway him to being the pitching Ace for a club he loved all his life? The signing of Cole is not the first time Cole and the Yankees have interacted. The Yankees drafted Cole in 2008, but Cole decided to attend college at UCLA. They were also outbid by the Pirates for Cole when he got out of college.



Cole attended Orange Lutheran High School and played on the team as a pitcher. In this sophomore year, he once pitched 45 innings without allowing a run. In his junior year, his fastball reached 94mph. At the start of his senior season, fifty baseball scouts would attend his opening start. He would go 8-2 that season with a .047 ERA while striking out 121. The Yankees would select Cole in the first-round draft in 2008, but Cole would attend college instead.

At UCLA, Cole’s introduction to college pitching would be a bit rude, as he faced more talented players. He would go 4-8 with an ERA of 3.49. His next year would be more successful as he went 11-4, with an ERA of 3.37 with 153 strikeouts. In 2011 Cole would sign with the Pittsburgh Pirates. Cole attended spring training in 2012 but was optioned to the Bradenton Marauders of the Florida State League. Cole pitched to a 2.90 ERA before being promoted to the Indianapolis Indians, a triple-A Pirates minor league team. There he would go 5-3 with a 2.91 ERA, in twelve starts.

Injuries on the Pirates would cause Cole to be brought up to the majors, he made his MLB debut on June 11, 2013. In his first appearance, he struck out his first batter in just three pitches. In the game, he would also get his first hit. He gave up two earned runs in the game but got his first win as a major league pitcher. He would go on to hit his first home run on Sept. 7, 2014, his second on August 26th and his third for the Pirates, on May 26, 2016, a three-run blast into the visitor’s bullpen.

For the Pirates he would go 10-7 in his first year, 11-5 in his second, and an amazing 19-8 in his third year while being an All-Star, MVP nominee, and coming in fourth in the Cy Young voting. He would have an offseason in 2016 going only 7-10. 2017 would be only slightly better when he went 12-12. At the end of the season, he would be traded to the Houston Astros. With a new pitching coach and new technologies, Cole would again find his form. He would go 15-5 in 2018 while posting a 2.88 ERA. Cole’s 2019 was even better going 20-5 with an ERA of 2.50.

During the 2019 postseason, Cole would get his second taste of postseason play, and he would dominate. In 2018 he would go 1-1 with a 3.46 ERA. He would go seven or more innings in all five of his 2019 starts, sometimes going over 100 pitches. On October 5 against the Rays in the ALDS he would not allow a run in the 3-1 win. On 10/10 he would again face the Rays and pitch to a .057 ERA in the win. On 10/15 he would lose to the Yankees but post an ERA of just .040. In the ALCS against the Nationals on 10/22, he would get a 5-4 win. To finish off his postseason, he would get another win against the Nationals on 10/27 while allowing only one run in the 7-1 Houston win. He would end the postseason 4-1, with an ERA of 1.72.

Once interviewed by David Laurila, he would ask Cole what his hitting approach is, Cole would answer “I try to get early contact and keep it on the ground. I like to keep the ball down as much as I can. Strikeouts are something that just happens. You don’t go for strikeouts, because your pitch count gets too high. When you do get that opportunity, you have to put them away with whatever is working that day. That’s the approach I’ve always had to have. I’ve got to keep my pitch count down. If you want to go deep into ballgames, you have to stay under that 100 mark.”

Cole is a fearless monster on the mound and attacks hitters. He is durable and goes deep into games, something that will rest the Yankee bullpen. In his short career, he has been an All-Star three times, been a MVP nominee twice, and has been voted for the Cy Young Award three times, coming in second in the voting this past year.

Although he has turned out to be the New York Yankees winningest pitcher, he doesn’t seem to be the dominant pitcher he was for the Houston Astros last year.  He appears to have struggled at times, even in the games that he has won.  Also, Cole has given up home runs, lot’s of them. He has given up a home run in every one of his starts.  The Yankees have lost the last four games that Cole started.  In those games, Cole gave up eight home runs while walking nine hitters. Last season he was 21-5 with an ERA of 2.51, this year his earned run average is considerably higher at 3.64.

One would have to assume, that this crazy baseball season, and it’s broken up spring training may have something to due with Cole’s performance.  There is another possibility, could he be another great pitcher to come to the Yankees and flop?  A.J. Burnett is the most recent overpaid pitching bust for the New York Yankees. He was not the first, the Yankees have had over a dozen premier pitchers to come to them in the last 30 years that couldn’t cut it in New York.

Cole and his family moved to Greenwich, CT a suburb of New York. The 6’4″ Cole is married to his wife Amy, who he met as a softball player at UCLA. His brother-in-law is Brandon Crawford of the San Francisco Giants. He and his wife love to cook and entertain family and friends. Cole is a healthy cook and a nutritional nut. Amy has a blog called “the Culinary Experience”. The two gave birth to a son earlier this summer. Cole has a younger sister Erin.