The New York Mets were reportedly in the running for free agent first baseman Carlos Santana before he signed a one-year, $12 million deal with the Cleveland Guardians. According to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, the Mets showed interest in Santana as they explored more cost-efficient options to address first base for the 2025 season.
A Budget-Friendly Option
Santana, a veteran switch-hitter, offered a combination of offensive production and defensive reliability at a reasonable price point. In 2024, Santana posted a .238/.328/.420 slash line with 23 home runs, 71 RBIs, and a 114 wRC+. He also won a Gold Glove at first base, making him an attractive option for a team looking to reinforce its infield without making a massive financial commitment.
The Mets’ interest in Santana indicates a potential desire to keep costs lower at the position, especially given their existing financial commitments to players like Juan Soto. Santana’s short-term deal would have allowed the Mets to maintain flexibility for future seasons while still addressing their immediate needs — possibly acquiring Alex Bregman to play third base.
Pete Alonso Still a Priority
Despite their interest in Santana, the Mets remain engaged in talks with Pete Alonso about a long-term contract. However, Alonso is expected to command a significantly higher salary, potentially exceeding $25 million annually. While Alonso provides elite power and has been a cornerstone of the Mets’ offense, the cost disparity between him and a player like Santana highlights the Mets’ balancing act as they weigh their options for 2025 and beyond.
- Yankees could sign the anti-Gleyber Torres to solve second base
- Yankees insider hints at possible ‘surplus of cash’ to make another big splash
- Yankees might have a sleeping dragon in the starting rotation
A Missed Opportunity for Depth
Ultimately, Santana’s decision to return to Cleveland leaves the Mets with fewer cost-effective options at first base. If they are unable to strike a deal with Alonso, they may need to pivot to a possible trade candidate. Santana’s blend of experience, switch-hitting power, and defensive skill would have been a valuable addition, but the Mets now face a more challenging path to solidifying their infield.