Sometimes a roster problem announces itself long before anyone is ready to deal with it. For the New York Mets, that alarm started blaring back in June, when the rotation unraveled and never truly stitched itself back together. You can lose an outfielder, patch over a bullpen spot, find a bench bat or two. But try competing without frontline starting pitching in today’s league and you’re signing up for a slow bleed. Everything the Mets have done, or failed to do, this winter points to the same conclusion: they know they can’t afford to get this part wrong.
The Mets are running out of safe bets
The Mets watched Dylan Cease land in Toronto, a gut punch not because he was perfect but because he represented a clear opportunity. Now the front office is sifting through alternatives like Tatsuya Imai, Ranger Suarez, and Framber Valdez. Each name carries intrigue, but none of them fit cleanly. Imai hasn’t thrown a pitch in Major League Baseball, and counting on NPB success to translate becomes trickier when your rotation already feels unstable. Suarez and Valdez have track records, but both have logged so many high-intensity innings that you can reasonably wonder if their best seasons are already in the rearview mirror.
This is how teams talk themselves into standing still. Options exist, just not the right ones. The Mets can’t let that happen again.
Tarik Skubal isn’t just an upgrade: He’s the upgrade
Skubal is a different conversation entirely. You don’t stumble upon a 29-year-old lefty who might be the best pitcher in the world and happens to be in his prime. You certainly don’t ignore one. Two straight AL Cy Young Awards, 469 strikeouts over the last two years, and an ERA that has fallen every year of his career until it rested at a ridiculous 2.21 last season. That profile doesn’t just check every box. It’s its own category.
When Jon Heyman reported that the Mets want Skubal and are debating whether to go all in, it felt like the first honest acknowledgment of their reality. This isn’t a luxury pursuit. This is the kind of move that resets the trajectory of a franchise. And the Mets, with their deep pool of big league-ready prospects, are one of the few clubs equipped for this kind of negotiation.
The price will be steep, but the clock is ticking
Of course, the Detroit Tigers don’t have to do anything. They can hang onto Skubal for one final push before he reaches free agency after 2026. They can slow-play the market and ask for the moon, which they absolutely will. In any trade scenario, they’re likely demanding a blend of MLB-ready contributors and high-end prospects knocking on the door. That’s the cost of acquiring a legitimate ace.
But here’s the flip side: the Mets have already lost Cease, Kyle Schwarber, Edwin Diaz, and Pete Alonso, among others this winter. Waiting for the perfect moment hasn’t helped them so far. At some point, a front office has to stop operating like it’s protecting something fragile and start acting like a team trying to win baseball games.
The move that changes everything
Skubal fits the Mets in a way that few players do. He addresses their most critical weakness, sets the tone for the entire pitching staff, and gives the organization a reason to plant a flag instead of explaining away another missed opportunity.
The Mets can choose patience again, but patience is how you end up watching other teams celebrate. And in a market thinning by the week, boldness might be the only real option left.
More about: New York Mets
