Blue Jays bolster their bullpen with divisional trade

The Toronto Blue Jays, owners of the best record in the American League, aren’t sitting back and waiting for October magic.

With a 63-45 record and a five-game cushion over the second-place New York Yankees, Toronto is firmly in the AL East driver’s seat.

But success in July doesn’t guarantee October glory—just ask any team haunted by postseason collapses of the past decade.

Despite their stellar record in the 2025 MLB regular season, the Blue Jays have been active in the trade season, speaking to many teams with multiple improvements in mind.

Toronto’s front office knows standing pat can be fatal down the stretch, especially when the bullpen shows signs of fatigue or instability.

Recognizing that need, the Blue Jays pulled off a divisional stunner on Tuesday by trading with the rival Baltimore Orioles.

Seranthony Domínguez Brings Power and Playoff Grit

The Blue Jays acquired right-hander Seranthony Domínguez, a reliever known for his electric stuff and dominant playoff performances.

In exchange, Toronto sent pitching prospect Juaron Watts-Brown to the Orioles, a move that balances present needs with future potential.

MLB insider Jeff Passan broke the deal, with confirmation from Canadian reporters Ben Nicholson-Smith and Shi Davidi.

Domínguez isn’t the steadiest reliever on paper, but few arms in the American League can match his upside when he’s locked in.

Across his career, Domínguez owns a solid 3.54 ERA, backed by a high-octane fastball and a devastating slider.

But it’s his postseason resume that truly stands out—just 1.02 ERA with 27 strikeouts in 17.2 intense October innings.

He’s the kind of reliever who can handle the weight of postseason moments, much like a closer slamming a vault door in a heist movie.

Toronto’s Bullpen Gets Reinforcements Where It Counts

Domínguez already looked sharp for Baltimore this season, pitching to a 3.24 ERA with 54 strikeouts over 41.2 innings.

Toronto needed that kind of reliability, especially with Jeff Hoffman struggling to a 4.78 ERA in high-leverage situations.

The Blue Jays have seen games slip away late, exposing a soft underbelly in an otherwise championship-caliber roster.

Adding Domínguez immediately shifts the bullpen dynamic, giving manager John Schneider a new weapon in close games.

He can now mix and match more effectively, without overusing struggling arms or asking starters to go too deep.

Domínguez’s presence also offers insurance against injuries or regression from other relievers during the dog days of August.

If the Jays are going to play meaningful baseball in October, depth and trust in the bullpen will be crucial.

A Calculated Gamble That Signals Championship Ambitions

Trading a promising arm like Juaron Watts-Brown doesn’t come easy, but this move shows Toronto is serious about winning now.

Watts-Brown has upside, but he’s still refining his command, and may be a few years away from making an MLB impact.

The Blue Jays had to weigh long-term development against the urgency of capitalizing on a rare window of opportunity.

They’re betting on Domínguez’s postseason experience, swing-and-miss stuff, and hunger to prove he’s still elite.

This move wasn’t just about numbers—it was about sending a message to the clubhouse and the rest of the league.

Toronto’s front office is signaling it believes this roster can win it all—and it’s going to do everything to support that mission.

Domínguez has the potential to be the final piece that holds everything together when the pressure spikes in October.

READ MORE: Guardians All-Star outfielder is generating ‘a ton’ of trade interest