You Can’t Be a Baseball “Purist” and Call Yourself a Yankee Fan

There’s been a lot of talk from baseball fans, New York Yankees fans are not exempt from this, over the proposed rule changes that would have gone into effect this season surrounding use of the bullpen, number of roster spots on the bench during the regular season, and the proposed expansion of the playoff format suggested by Manfred that wouldn’t go into effect until 2022, after the current CBA expires.

Many people who chastise Commissioner Manfred are arguing “There’s no reason to change the rules of baseball. Baseball is perfect as is!” To which I counter “If you’re a left-handed relief pitcher on a major league roster, and you can’t get out a right-handed batter (and they make up the VAST majority of major league hitters), go back to the minor leagues and figure it out or retire.” But for all you “Old person yell’s at cloud” Yankee “fans” saying you shouldn’t change the rules of baseball, here are key moments in Yankee history you’re saying the Yankees should give back. Because these Yankees success stories hinged on baseball CHANGING THE RULES!

You Want to Give Back the 2017 Playoff Run?

The Yankees weren’t the division winner in 2017, they had to battle it out in the Wild Card game (I use battle loosely as it was over after inning 1) to get to the ALCS, after almost getting swept by the Indians in the Divisional round. The Wild Card play-in game didn’t exist until 2012. I hated it, but it was the only way the Yankees made the playoffs between 2013 and 2018.

You Want to Give Back the 90’s Dynasty?

The Yankees weren’t the division winners in 1996. They were the Wild Card team. The Wild Card wasn’t introduced until 1994, and not properly implemented until 1995/1996 because of the strike in 1994. If you hate baseball rule changes, the Yankees don’t win 4 titles in 5 years. Hell, they may not even win in 1998.

You Want to Give Up the Designated Hitter?

So many Yankee fans don’t want to see Giancarlo Stanton play left field, they just want him to hit DH. The DH wasn’t introduced until 1973. Which would mean that if you don’t want to “change baseball”, you actually want to see Stanton be the everyday left fielder?

You Want to Give Up the ALCS and Divisions?

For the longest time, baseball playoffs were a simple postseason format. The team with the best record in the AL played the team with the best record in the NL. Divisions didn’t exist until 1969. That same year, they introduced the Championship Series in the playoffs.

You Want to Give Up the 162 Game Season?

Some Yankee fans are clamoring for the full 162 game season to be played in 2020. That didn’t exist until 1961, the year Marris hit 61. The baseball season ended around Labor Day. That’s pretty much what we can expect this season.

You Want to Go Back to the Dead Ball Era?

Live ball baseball came about because of a RULE CHANGE! It’s also largely around this time that Babe Ruth became a Yankee, and moved from being predominantly a pitcher to becoming predominantly a hitter.

You Want to Raise the Mound Again?

The current height of the pitching mound came about because Bob Gibson was UNTOUCHABLE in 1968. To ensure no one had that impressive of a season again, the current baseball mound came to be.

So, when guys like Goose Gossage bemoan all the rule changes, and people start parroting what he’s saying, it sickens me. It sickens me because he knows better, and you all know better. But you want something to be mad at, so you decide to listen to him. If it weren’t for all the rule changes baseball has made throughout the years, who knows if the Yankees even became the perennial team in baseball? Who knows if the Mets ever come into existence?

Baseball will be back, but they are first and foremost, a business. Like the NFL. The NFL changes rules almost every season to try and keep people entertained and engaged. Why shouldn’t baseball take similar actions?

New York Yankees News: Arizona and Florida Governors okay with plan to start baseball in their states

New York Yankees

Baseball Commission Rob Manfred is working with the New York Yankees and the other 29 major league teams to get baseball started against while the coronavirus drags on.  He is also working with federal health officials and the governors of Arizona and Florida to use facilities in their states to get a start to America’s summer pastime.

Recently Manfred issued one plan to get baseball going by isolating it in both Arizona and Florida, where there is already a baseball infrastructure.  In Arizona, baseball would use the retractable roof Chase Stadium home of the Arizona Diamondbacks of the National League.  It is likely that doubleheaders and even tripleheaders would be played there in an attempt to get as many games in as possible.  The 30 MLB teams would also use open-air minor league and college stadiums within a 50-mile radius of Pheonix.  Although many New York Yankee fans are in favor of the plan just to be able to play, they also cite isolation from their families as an issue.

Florida is also be considered.  In the dual state plan, the Grapefruit league would be played there, and Cactus League games played in Arizona.  There is a lot of pushback for both plans as they would have environmental obstacles as well as causing players to be away from their families for an entire season.  The plans would cause the players to isolate themselves in hotels and only be allowed to travel between hotels and stadiums.  Florida is the home of the New York Yankees George M. Steinbrenner Field; it’s major training facility.

Another plan put forth makes less sense, still allowing players to engage in air travel and play teams that are not in their usual divisions.  This plan would create an entirely illegitimate season with a meaningless World Championship.

Both the Arizona Governor Doug Ducey and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis have both indicated that they are okay with starting baseball in their states.  Ducey said:

“I have had discussions [Manfred],” Ducey said, via the Arizona Republic. “While I want to hold the content of those discussions in confidence, I just want everyone to know that Arizona, at the right time, is very open-minded to hosting whatever Major League Baseball would like from the state, at the time that it would be appropriate for public health if Arizona were in a position to reopen.

“We have the facilities that are here. We have the hotel space that is here. We want to make sure that the metrics and data are proper before we are able to go forward.”

Florida Governor DeSantis has deemed sports as “essential businesses” in the state, too.  Florida has over 21k active cases of the coronavirus in the state and Arizona has 3,800 cases as of Tuesday night, according to the New York Times.

One of these plans may be adopted or neither may take effect as Manfred mules over what to do to complete some type of baseball season.  He just may wait until it is safe to have baseball at New York Yankees Stadium and in other MLB home parks.  That would be a best option in this writer’s opinion, where a traditional season of 80 or so games could be played.  Manfred is not going to rush into starting the season but must make some decisions as to what a season will look like in the next few weeks.

“MLB has been working diligently to plan for many different contingencies, as one of many ideas that has been discussed has been to play some of our games in Florida when the public health situation allows for it,” the league said in a statement on Tuesday, via Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times. “We are appreciative that the Governor is open to playing games in Florida as one potential solution, but we all agree that such efforts can only be undertaken in a manner that does not endanger public health, nor the health of our players and fans. We will continue to be guided by those principles.”

New York’s mayor, Bill de Blasio, said today that he doubts that large gatherings would be allowed during June or July and possibly even August.  It should be noted that the major is a die-hard Boston Red Sox fan, although I’m sure that will have nothing to do with when Yankee Stadium can be opened to fans. One thing we call all agree on is that New York Yankees fans are starved for baseball and just want to hear the phrase, “Play Ball!”

New York Yankees: MLB makes stunning team re-alignment suggestion: Find out what fans think

For the past week, New York Yankees fans have been pondering the stunning, if not radical, plan that MLB is floating to completely re-align what teams play each other as sports adapt to how to get back to games during the coronavirus pandemic.

This writer has spent days pouring over every story written about the plan.  Writers pros and cons, and it got me to thinking what do real Yankee fans feel about all of this?  I conducted an informal poll on Facebook Yankee fan groups to see just what the average fan feels about not playing the traditional rivals.

MLB has suggested the possibility of re-aligning divisions into more or less geographic regions.  Instead of playing against traditional division rivals, the plan would look more like the Grapefruit and Cactus Leagues of spring training.

The plan would be broken down into six divisions:  Grapefruit North, which would pit the New York Yankees against the Toronto Blue Jays, the Detroit Tigers, the Philadelphia Phillies, and the Pittsburgh Pirates.  The South would include Boston Red Sox, Minnesota Twins, Atlanta Braves, Tampa Bay Rays, Baltimore Orioles.  The East would consist of Washington Nationals, Houston Astros, New York Mets, St. Louis Cardinals, Miami Marlins.

The Cactus League would include the Northeast, Chicago Cubs, San Francisco Giants, Arizona Diamondbacks, Colorado Rockies, Oakland Athletics.  The West: Los Angeles Dodgers, Chicago White Sox, Cincinnati Reds, Cleveland Indians, Los Angeles Angels.  The Northwest would include Milwaukee Brewers, San Diego Padres, Seattle Mariners, Texas Rangers, Kansas City Royals.

Where any of these games would be played is yet to be determined by MLB.  With wanting to get a baseball season this year, those determinations and details will have to be worked out in the next few weeks.  An original proposal to have all 30 MLB teams play the whole season in the Pheonix area seems less likely as the coronavirus is slowed and playing in home parks seems more feasible.

Although I am not totally against re-alignment to get in as many games as possible and at the same time protect players and fans, I can’t quite get a handle on how they figured this out.  Boston Red Sox in the south?  Cleveland Indians in the west?  Houston Astros in the East.  The only way this makes sense is if a bunch of MLB gurus sat around a big table hashing this out while smoking funny cigarettes.

The results of my poll although unscientific, were quite interesting for several reasons.  One is that the number of those in favor of the plan and those against it was pretty well equal, showing that fans may be as unsettled about what to do as the MLB seems to be.  54% don’t like the plan, and 38% are in favor of it.  What surprised me was that usually when I put forth a poll, people vote, and that’s it.  In this poll, New York Yankee fans not only voted but commented on the subject heavily.

In one of the Facebook Yankee groups, Yankee Fans R us!! for which I am an administrator, the group owner Michael Miracco said: “We have interleague play anyway, they’re all MLB teams.”  A moderator Mark Walsh noted in greater detail:

” I don’t know what to think, you’re taking Boston and Tampa Bay out of our division. To me that means we won’t play them except maybe in a postseason. Since when is Boston in the South. At the end of the day, if it’s only for this year, I can deal with it.”

That brings me to the other group represented in the poll.  Those that would agree, if not wholeheartedly, to the plan, if it was the only way we could have a baseball season (8%).  Many were citing; we just want to have some New York Yankee baseball to watch.

Although it was not reflected in the voting, many Yankee fans said they are more concerned about the player’s health, and the season should be canceled altogether in favor of starting fresh in 2021.  Those that responded that way, however, are definitely in the minority.  Most all will be satisfied with not attending games but want some ball played in the near future.  Whatever it takes!

On a side note, many New York Yankee fans still feel cheated by the Houston Astros, and feel Commission Rob Manfred failed when he didn’t strip the Astros of their World Series title and rings.  That dissatisfaction with Manfred seems to have carried over to most of those same fans now, citing that they are become more disgruntled with him and wish he would leave baseball alone.

This writer tends to agree with that.  I feel to have a legitimate season this year; we need to wait until it is safe to have a traditional albeit shortened season and play in the conventional divisions at the team’s home stadiums.  The re-alignment proposed with not significantly cut down on air travel, that is mostly done on chartered flights anyway.  What it will do is make a season that will be totally illegitimate with a World Championship that will be, for the most part, meaningless.


MLB, Players Association Agree on Plan For Shortened Season

New York Yankees, Marcus Stroman

The COVID-19 pandemic has created a halt in our world which has never been seen during this current generation. On what would have been Major League Baseball‘s opening day, the MLB and Players Association agreed on how the upcoming shortened season will be handled.

According to Ken Rosenthal, players will receive $170 million in advance to spread over two months.  The future salaries will be pro-rated on the number of games played in the abbreviated 2020 season. The deal should be completed Friday and it will also put roster moves on hold. This is why the Mets were actively trimming their roster over the last week.

Draft and Service Time Changes

Much like the NFL, MLB will continue to hold their draft as scheduled. There will be at least five rounds to the draft but it puts teams in a tough spot. With the entire NCAA season cancelled and high school season currently on hold, it makes the guessing game for each organization even harder. Some players who were also projected to leave school early may end up remaining at their respective schools to boost their draft stock.

No matter what happens with the season, players will still receive a year of service time as long as they were on the active roster or injured list. This means Yoenis Cespedes, Marcus Stroman, and Justin Wilson are just a few of the guys who will have their futures based off a small sample size. Michael Conforto, Edwin Diaz and Brandon Nimmo headline a strong crew of Mets who will have very little to work off of when they head towards arbitration.

New York Yankees: 5 Scenarios affecting a Yankee 2020 baseball season!

1. Yankees and MLB  take back seat to COVID-19

The New York Yankees, like all of MLB, is at a halt.  The COVID-19 virus, also known as coronavirus, is front and center in the news and everyone’s daily life.  With more significant restrictions, each day as to the size of gatherings, the Yankees, as well as all of the sports is taking a back seat to the deadly disease.  The virus is growing at an alarming rate, as the death toll rises, Yankee fans’ thoughts have shifted from the loss of baseball to their own health and that of their families.  Believe it or not Yankees fans may have put the Houston Astros cheating scandal in the rear-view mirror.

2. What to do with Yankee players and workers

With no baseball at the moment or in the near future, it has created all kinds of questions for MLB.  The MLB and the players union are going to have to decide how players will be paid during the CDC imposed work stoppage.  MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has had to put aside the final parts of the Boston Red Sox cheating investigation as his attention has had to turn to the questions regarding the baseball season.  As far as baseball workers in the stadiums around the country, MLB has mandated that all teams will donate $1 million to augment unemployment checks until baseball returns.

3. When will the season start

When the New York Yankees baseball season starts is the question of the day.  The Yankees have no control over that.  According to present guidance from the CDC, it appears and mini spring training could happen in late May with an early June start to the regular season.  This, of course, is a best-case scenario.  MLB has already said that it will follow CDC guidelines.

4.  What will the 2020 Season look like?

What the New York Yankee season will look like is an intriguing situation.  Again, the Yankees won’t have much control over that.  All the teams, along with MLB, will make those decisions as it gets closer to a time that baseball can start.  Different scenarios include baseball in November or a 120 game season.  Whatever happens to the season, there will definitely be an asterisk after the season, lessening the genuine feel of the season.  The season may do away with interleague games, and you may see more doubleheaders to get more games in.

The New York Yankees, the Houston Astros the Tampa Bay Rays,  Minnesota Twins, Los Angeles Dodgers and Washington Nationals all seem to be headed to postseason play.  If the season is extended, we may find postseason games played in domed stadiums and neutral fields.  Picture a Yankee National World Series with all seven games played at the Miami Marlins Park in 75-degree weather.  The season could start with no fans in the stands, that’s not out of the question.

5.  For the Yankees, it’s a time to heal

Although there is very little good about the baseball season delay, it does have it’s benefits for the Yankees.  Earlier, we learned that Luis Severino would miss the entire season again due to Tommy John surgery.  James Paxton had back surgery and would miss the first two months or so of the season.  The delay in the start of the season will minimize the loss of pitching time.  Aaron Judge, with a rib fracture, will have more time to heal.  The same goes for Giancarlo Stanton with this calf strain.  Catcher Gary Sanchez will have more time to get over his back soreness.  The delay in the start of the season just may make the Yankees whole and ready to go when the bell sounds.

MLB Summary

MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has made it clear that whatever decisions are made about the upcoming season, no matter how imperfect, will be better than the alternative.  No baseball season at all.

New York Yankees: Is Commissioner Manfred being tough enough?

There is much talk in the baseball world as to whether Rob Manfred is being tough enough on sign-stealing rule breakers that may have changed the outcome of postseason results.  According to who you listen to the answer is all over the place.  One news organization in Los Angeles is calling for the World Series loss in 2017 to be overturned and be awarded to the Dodgers.  CC Sabathia said yesterday that he feels cheated out of another World Series ring.  Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred issued his nine-page report on Monday.  The report detailed the sign-stealing that was conducted by the Houston Astros during the 2017 season.  The punishments issued included a one-year suspension of Astros Manager A.J. Hinch and General Manager Jeff Luhnow, a $5MM fine, the loss of first and second-round draft picks in 2020 and 2021.  In addition, the former Assitant General Manager was made ineligible.

At first look, many were pleased with the punishment that the Astros would endure, but the overnight trend seemed to change to think it was not all that stuff.  With all this disagreement with how Manfred handed this, I decided to conduct an informal non-scientific poll across several Yankee Facebook groups representing 35k Yankee fans.  I presented the poll with several options from Life bans to the feeling that the punishments issued by Manfred were too harsh.   Because the poll was taken of Yankee fans, it obviously does not include the feeling of all in baseball, just Yankee fans who would tend to want harsher treatment of the Astros.

Here are the results of those that voted in the 24-hour poll.   I feel the World Series title should be stripped and Championship rings returned: 59%.  All players and managers involved should be suspended: 21%.  I am satisfied with punishments issued: 18%.  I believe all players and managers should be suspended for life: less than 1%.  The punishments are too harsh: less than 1%.   The poll among Yankee fans shows that the general opinion is that although the punishments issued were appropriate they were not harsh enough and the Houston Astros should have been stripped of their World Series Title.  What we don’t know is if Manfred is saving his harshest treatment for Astros coach and Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora who has already been fired by the Red Sox.