Just as the New York Yankees were starting to find their rhythm, another injury has thrown their lineup into disarray.
Following Monday night’s 4-1 loss to the Minnesota Twins, the team revealed Paul Goldschmidt was dealing with knee inflammation.
The timing couldn’t be worse, as his absence removes one of their most dangerous right-handed bats against left-handed pitching.
Goldschmidt’s reliability in these matchups has been a key piece of their offensive approach all season.
Missed opportunity against Minnesota highlights the problem
On Wednesday night, the Yankees faced a critical at-bat with a lefty on the mound and the game hanging in the balance.
Instead of calling on Goldschmidt, who owns a .404 average against lefties, they left struggling catcher Austin Wells in the game.
Wells struck out with little resistance, raising questions about the decision and underscoring Goldschmidt’s value in such moments.
Against left-handed pitching, few on the roster can match his track record, especially in high-leverage situations late in games.
Losing him in these moments is like removing a queen from your chessboard right before a decisive attack.
The domino effect on the rest of the lineup
Goldschmidt’s absence doesn’t just affect pinch-hitting options — it changes defensive alignments and forces difficult choices behind the plate.
With him unavailable at first base, Ben Rice shifts over, meaning Wells must start more frequently at catcher.
Rice has been thriving both offensively and defensively as a catcher, making the switch feel like a downgrade in multiple areas.
Wells, on the other hand, has been mired in a brutal slump since the All-Star break, hitting just .111 with a .354 OPS.
On the year, his .206 average and .672 OPS paint the picture of a bat struggling to stay relevant in the lineup.
Yankees can’t afford extended struggles at catcher
The combination of Wells’ offensive decline and Goldschmidt’s injury leaves the Yankees vulnerable in both contact and power production.
Every plate appearance matters in a tight postseason race, and they can’t afford dead spots in the batting order.
If Goldschmidt’s knee keeps him sidelined for long, the pressure on other hitters to pick up the slack will only intensify.
The Yankees have weathered lineup adversity before, but this situation is testing both their depth and their in-game flexibility.
Much will depend on how quickly Goldschmidt can return and reestablish the balance he’s brought to the order all year.
More about: New York Yankees
