New York Yankees: Can the Yankees survive without Brett Gardner?

New York Yankees, Brett Gardner

At the end of the New York Yankees’ 2021 ended with a loss in the wild card game to the Boston Red Sox. At the end of the 2020 season, many, if not most, Yankee fans felt Brett Gardner’s time with the Yankees was coming to a close. Just days before the start of the 2021 season Gardner still had not been re-signed, but in the final days of the offseason, Gardner and the Yankees came to a deal bringing the 14-year veteran back for yet another year. Most of this was powered by Gardner’s desire to play at least one more year with fans in the stands. The same is true this year, he is not ready to give up the game he loves.

When Yankees resigned him, the plan was to use him as a versatile bench player. The reality is that he has been anything but that, playing in 140 games to date,plus the one wild card game. mostly due to the need to have him on the field with the many outfield injuries, especially to Aaron Hicks and Clint Frazier, causing Gardner to be the teams’ everyday centerfielder. But now, in the postseason run, Gardner had become a must-be in the lineup, hitting .325 in September. For some fleeting reason, Gardner has heated up in September and has helped the Yankees reach the postseason in the last three seasons. He ended the season with a .222 average and 10 home runs.Like the heralded legend Yogi Berra once quipped, “it’s not over till it’s over.” Though never the team’s superstar, Gardner shows us he still has much to do with his baserunning and defense, and can still be clutch getting a walk-off win, one night he went with a bloop single that gave the Yankees the win. He went 3 for 4 with 2 singles and a double driving in two of the Yankees 4 runs. Mister September?

When the terms of the Gardner deal were made known, Jon Heyman of the MLB Network reported that the contract includes $1.85 million and a $1 million signing bonus in 2021 as well a player and a club option for 2022. Gardner’s player option in 2022 would be worth $2.3 million and would convert to a $7.15 million club option or $1.15 million buyouts if it is not exercised. This means we may not be seeing the last of the Yankees’ only holdover from the 2009 World Series-winning season, especially if he was a high-impact player for the rest of the 2021 season.

The Yankees in an early move had said they will not exercise their team options and Gardner will not exercise his making him a free agent. Understand that does not mean Gardner will not be back with the Yankees, it only means not at the given prices, and if he does sign a new contract probably be the Yankees’ last piece of business before spring training. The Yankees have much to do with little money to do it with little money to do it with. The Yankees will keep the tandem if Sanchez and Higashioka. They may spend a a bit to retain Gardner as Hicks insurance, if any big money is spent it will be for a new shortstop.

For newer Yankee fans and those not born when he started his career with the Yankees, here is his story and path to the Yankees. After twleve years in the majors with the New York Yankees, Brett Gardner had one of his best seasons in 2019.  He is already the veteran heart and soul of the New York Yankees. For those that think Brett is washed up, he had an above-average season. In 2019 he had 123 hits and 74 runs batted in, his third-best RBI record with the Yankees. He also hit a career-high 28 home runs, making him a power threat. Gardner was clutch in many of his hits. His speed on the bases and in the field was as good as ever.

Fast forward to the 2020 season. Brett’s performance dropped off considerably, as it happened with many players during the shortened coronavirus season. One difference was that it was the last year of his contract, and the New York Yankees would have to decide whether to exercise his $10 million option for the 2021 season. They did not and bought him out for $2.5 million, making him a free agent.

Gardner always said he wanted to come back to the Yankees and retire as a Yankee. After no fans in the stands, Gardner wanted to play another season so his family could see him play again. As the offseason lingered, no offer came from the Yankees. Gardner had to decide whether to investigate other interested teams or if he should retire. Gardner held fast to the idea he could return to the Yankees. Finally, just before spring training, he got an offer from the Yankees that he accepted. After all, he is the defacto captain of the New York Yankees.

At spring training at the George M. Steinbrenner training facility in St. Petersburg, Florida, Gardner was happy as a lark and excited to contribute to the 2021 season. However, this season will be like no other; he will not be in the starting lineup but playing from the bench neither happened, he played in 140 games, he found himself as an everyday player. At the time of his new contract, he said:“Whatever the team needs me to do to help on a daily basis, I’ll be ready. Whatever my role is, I accept it.”

Gardner was born on a farm in Holly Hill, South Carolina, a boy was born to Jerry and Faye Gardner on August 24, 1983. That son was Brett Gardner. Brett grew up on that farm in his Dad’s shadow, a minor league baseball player in the Philadelphia Phillies organization. So it was natural that Brett would play baseball for the local American Legion post and play the game when he attended Holly Hill Academy. When he attended the College of Charleston in 2001, he decided to try out for their baseball team as a walk-on.

He ended up playing 3 years as a starter for the team. In his senior year, he batted .447, tied for the most hits in all of college baseball with 122, established a Cougars record with 85 runs scored, and led the Southern Conference with 38 stolen bases. After his senior year, the Yankees selected Brett in the third round of the draft.

From 2005 to 2006, he played for the New York Penn League and Florida State League. In 2007 he played for the Trenton Thunder managed to hit five triples and batted .300 with a
.392 OBP before being promoted to the Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Rail Riders. On June 30, 2008, Gardner was called up and made his major league debut, batting leadoff and going 0-for-3 with a stolen base. On September 21, 2008, Gardner scored the final run of Major League Baseball in old Yankee Stadium history as a pinch-runner for Jason Giambi, scoring on a sacrifice fly by Robinson Canó in the seventh inning of an eventual 7–3 win for the Yankees over the Baltimore Orioles.

Brett has spent most of his career in the left outfield and as a leadoff
batter due to his speed and ability to steal bases. When Curtis Granderson suffered an injury in 2013, Brett moved to the center field to excel. Although Brett will never be under consideration for the Hall of Fame, he has certainly excelled with the Yankees winning the Fielding Bible Award in 2010, 2011, and 2017. He was an All-Star in 2015, was AL Stolen base leader in 2011, AL triples leader in 2013, Gold Glove winner in 2016, and earned a World Series Champion ring in 2009. He still holds the team record the most stolen bases among active players.

Brett’s stats have been declining a bit in the last few years as he ages but is still the heart and soul of the New York Yankees. When Brett steps to the plate, he is going to run up pitches for whoever is pitching. He is the most disciplined Yankee at the plate, making contact on 93% of his swings. No player has played harder than Brett, and that continues to this day. Even though he hasn’t been a star in the last few years, he has always heated up toward the end of the season. This year was no different. He also over the last several years been the only Yankee to stay healthy. He was one of only two players that did not go on the IL.

He spends the offseason near his Dad’s 2,600-acre farm. Brett recently talked about spending the shutdown time helping out his Dad. Brett and his wife live in Summerville, South Carolina. Brett and his wife Jessica have two boys, Abraham, born in 2008, and Peter, born in 2010. At age 37, his playing years may be coming to an end, but he will always be remembered as a guy who put everything he had into every game.’s Columnist William Parlee is a member of the Society for American Baseball Research. Follow me on Twitter @parleewilliam


© 2021 Empire Sports Media

Mentioned in this article:

More about: