A strange thing happens when a reliever with a track record suddenly can’t land a pitch where he wants it. You can almost feel the tension ripple through a dugout. The New York Mets lived that reality with Ryan Helsley this past summer, watching a reliable late-inning arm from St. Louis unravel the moment he touched Queens soil. It wasn’t for lack of stuff. It was because hitters knew what was coming.
A Move That Never Found Its Rhythm
Helsley’s 3.00 ERA with the Cardinals felt like a solid foundation for a contender trying to stabilize the bridge to Edwin Diaz. There was no grand expectation that he’d morph into an untouchable weapon. The Mets just needed competence. What they got was a pitcher tipping his pitches so clearly that opponents looked like they were reading tomorrow’s scouting report. A 7.20 ERA in 20 New York innings doesn’t happen by accident. It happens when hitters are too comfortable and a pitcher is too unsure of his own delivery.
The Mets kept waiting for the switch to flip back, but his struggles never let up. Walks came in bunches, and even his usually electric fastball couldn’t bail him out. By late September, with the postseason slipping away, Helsley’s time in orange and blue had run out. Rentals are ruthless that way. If they hit, they’re heroic. If they don’t, they vanish as quickly as they arrived.
A Market That Still Believed
What made his next chapter interesting was the sheer volume of teams that still believed in the arm. Up to 15 clubs checked in, some with a surprising twist. A few front offices didn’t just want to fix him; they wanted to stretch him out. The Detroit Tigers were among the teams imagining him as a starter, betting on athleticism and raw stuff rather than recent performance. For a pitcher who spent the last two months searching for feel, that kind of curiosity from other organizations says a lot about how teams evaluate talent versus turmoil.
But in the end, Helsley didn’t reinvent himself. He doubled down on what he knows. Jeff Passan’s report on Saturday made it official: Helsley is heading to the Baltimore Orioles on a two-year deal with an opt-out after the first season. He stays on the East Coast, jumps to the American League, and immediately inherits ninth-inning duties until Felix Bautista returns from injury. For Baltimore, it’s a gamble on upside at a time when they can afford to shop in that aisle. For Helsley, it’s a chance to prove New York was the outlier, not the trend.
What It Means for the Mets
His full 2025 ledger was uneven but not disastrous: a 4.50 ERA across 56 innings with 63 strikeouts and 25 walks. Those numbers can stabilize with the right tweaks. They can also sink a bullpen if the pitch-tipping issues linger. The Orioles clearly believe it’s closer to the former.
The Mets, for their part, didn’t push to bring him back and weren’t among the finalists. That tells its own story. New York has several bullpen holes to fill and wants reliability more than a project. Their offseason board reflects that urgency, with names like Diaz, Devin Williams, Robert Suarez, and Pete Fairbanks sitting near the top of the list. The Mets need stability after too many nights spent watching games slip away in the seventh and eighth.
Helsley’s departure doesn’t leave a scar so much as it closes a brief and bewildering chapter. Sometimes a move just doesn’t work, and the Mets recognized it early enough not to chase the sunk cost. Now both sides get a reset. Baltimore gets the upside. The Mets get clarity.
And as the offseason unfolds, we’ll learn whether this bullpen reshuffle becomes a turning point or just another footnote in a year full of them.
More about: New York Mets
