The New York Mets and Pete Alonso have been here before — locked in a standoff that feels more personal than transactional. Last winter’s negotiations dragged on for months, a tug-of-war between a slugger chasing his worth and a front office wary of long-term commitments. They eventually found middle ground on a two-year, $54 million deal with an opt-out after 2025. But after another strong offensive season, Alonso pulled the trigger early, testing the market once again.
This time, the stakes are even higher. Alonso just hit 38 home runs, finished with a .871 OPS, and reminded everyone that when he’s right, he’s one of baseball’s purest power hitters. For a Mets lineup that struggled with consistency and identity, his bat was often the heartbeat. But now, that familiar uncertainty looms: will the Mets pay their homegrown star, or let him walk away?
Tension Returns to Queens
If you believe the early whispers, it doesn’t look promising. Insiders like Pat Ragazzo and Bob Nightengale have suggested that the Mets aren’t expected to meet Alonso’s asking price, predicting that both sides could part ways this winter. It’s not a new tune for Mets fans — a frustrating refrain of financial caution and mixed messaging.
But not everyone is buying into the doom-and-gloom narrative. MLB insider Andy Martino offered a different perspective, pushing back on the idea that Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns has already closed the door. “In the early days of the offseason, a perception has seemed to congeal that Alonso is a goner,” Martino wrote, “and that Stearns does not want him. The former is inaccurate because it is way premature. The latter is inaccurate because… well, it just is.”
Martino painted Stearns as more human than many assume — a lifelong Mets fan who once hid a radio under his pillow just to hear Gary Cohen and Bob Murphy call games. That detail matters. It suggests that Stearns, despite his reputation as a calculated executive, understands the emotional weight of Alonso’s presence in Queens.
Between Logic and Loyalty
Of course, nostalgia alone won’t shape the Mets’ roster decisions. Stearns has built his career on discipline — on avoiding long-term commitments to players whose value could decline quickly. And Alonso, for all his power, fits that risk profile. He’s entering his age-31 season and doesn’t provide much value defensively, seeing his metrics in the field crater last season with -9 Defensive Runs Saved and -9 Outs Above Average.
Still, as Martino hinted, declaring Alonso’s exit a done deal might be premature. This same front office nearly reached that point before, only for cooler heads to prevail. It’s entirely possible both sides find a middle ground again — perhaps one where Alonso spends more time as the designated hitter while keeping his role as middle-of-the-lineup thumper and fan favorite.
What Comes Next
The truth is, the Mets are at a crossroads. Letting Alonso walk would signal a shift toward a colder, more data-driven era, where sentiment takes a back seat to projection models. Keeping him, on the other hand, would reaffirm a connection between the team and its fans that numbers can’t measure.
As of now, both paths are still open. Negotiations could heat up or fall apart entirely. What’s clear is that this won’t be a quick process — and Mets fans are bracing for another long, emotional offseason.
Will the Mets value the power, the history, and the bond Alonso represents? Or will practicality win out once more? Either way, this decision will say a lot about what kind of team New York wants to be.
More about: New York Mets
