While it seems the New York Knicks have instilled their faith in Dennis Smith Jr. for the 2019-20 season, I wouldn’t be so sure moving forward. Reports have made compelling arguments new veteran signing Elfrid Payton could emerge as the starter.
Smith Jr. has worked this off-season to improve his jump shot and potential scoring efficiency, something he has struggled with during his first two seasons in the NBA. With training camp just one month away, the Knicks are preparing to situate their starting five on the roster and what point guard will ultimately earn the most playing time.
Here is how we rank the point guards for the New York Knicks:
1.) Elfrid Payton
While Dennis has elite athleticism, Payton is the more efficient point guard in nearly every category. Compared to Smith’s 2.8 rebounds per game last season, Elfrid earned 5.3.
Also, Smith has never averaged over 5.2 assists in a season, while Payton has never fallen below 6.2 per game and his five-year NBA career. Comparing the two side-by-side, Smith is a bit more versed in scoring, but that is likely due to his mentality and desire to attack the rim.
Payton is a more patient point guard that looks to expand the floor and move the ball around. That makes him a bit more valuable for the Knicks this upcoming season unless Smith can prove that he is a more well-rounded player and is willing to operate as a traditional point guard.
2.) Dennis Smith Jr.
Head coach David Fizdale may elect to stick with Smith moving forward as the starter. He is the younger option in regards to Alfred Payton, which is likely why the Knicks want him on the floor and gaining experience. They view him as the future at the position for the team, making him even more valuable. Payton can necessarily be his mentor and help him develop this upcoming season. Increasing his rebounding and assist totals will be a priority for him. Also, his jump shot in field-goal efficiency will be a focal point.
3.) Frank Ntilikina
The disappointing story of Frank Ntilikina is ultimately winding down to a close. The French point guard has struggled to leave his mark on the NBA with inadequate scoring production, averaging just 5.9 points per game in his two-year NBA career. Additionally, he averages fewer rebounds per game than Smith and significantly fewer assists. He’s a very talented defender, which makes him a scenario-centric play, but he cannot be trusted to put points on the board with regular minutes.